A few residents of Canyon Country have restarted their efforts toward the creation of a new unified kindergarten-through-12th-grade school district.
The creation of this district is a bad idea, and fortunately doomed to almost certain failure. Unfortunately, in the process of trying to create this district, we will almost certainly rekindle the “us vs. them” feelings that so often crop up in our valley.
Why is this such a bad idea? The proponents point to a feasibility study that was bought by the current Sulphur Springs board “proving” that it is a great idea.
The study was written by two CPAs from a Sacramento company who visited our valley a few times. They failed to uncover many of the fantastic offerings available throughout the existing William S. Hart Union High School District.
Would the new district have programs similar to the existing remedial program for 9th graders offered at the Passport Academy? Would the new district have something that serves the needs of credit-deficient 16-year-olds similar to the existing Bowman Continuation High School? Could the new Canyon Country district afford to offer a program at College of the Canyons for 10th and 11th graders who wish to get a head start on their college education?
How would the needs of students who need an alternative program such as that offered through the Learning Post be served? How would the new district serve the state-mandated services to developmentally disabled adults that are currently served at Pleasantview in Saugus? Would the new district be able to obtain approval to create a new Junior ROTC program similar to the one currently attended by Canyon High School students at Valencia High?
In the real world, the answers to these questions are not going to serve all the needs of Canyon Country students. With a much smaller high school-aged population, the new district will simply not be able to afford the vast breadth of opportunities currently available in the Hart District.
The proponents tout the advantages of “local control.” In this argument is buried what I believe to be the real agenda of those who are pushing this idea— control. Wouldn’t we be better served by focusing on the best possible results in educating our children and building character, rather than who controls the governing board?
The proponents believe the new board will be more sensitive to the desires of the Canyon Country parents. This implied “dig” against the current Hart board is certainly not deserved. Anyone who has ever attended a Hart board meeting knows the current board is deeply concerned with the concerns of all parents and residents of our valley.
Out of curiosity, I checked the phone book to see if I could call my representatives to the board— if I wanted to. I didn’t actually try to call (as I have no real issues to discuss with them), but I did find a phone number for most, if not all, of the current board members. This is not a board that is “out of touch” or not working for the best possible education of all students in our valley. (We should applaud our current board for delivering outstanding results with state funding that is far less than the national average.)
When other arguments fail, the proponents have resorted to using the sensationalistic argument that we do not want our children educated by another “LAUSD.” To compare our current Hart district, with its four high schools, or even the future Hart district (when the valley is built out in 30 years), is laughable. Our eventual 300,000 residents will never compare to the millions who reside within the boundaries of LAUSD.
For these reasons, and many others, the state Board of Education will deny the request even if the proponents are able to collect the 15,000 signatures that will be required on the petition. If the state board was unable to reach the proper conclusion (denying the petition), the voters will reject this assault on the valley’s children.
But, in pushing this idea, the proponents will do a great deal of damage to this valley. We have already heard loud and clear from the parents in the schools to be pared away from the Saugus district; they are angry. I anticipate more hard feelings as the proponents try to take the newest school (LaMesa) and the planned Golden Valley High School from the Hart district. Others in Canyon Country are very happy with the outstanding results delivered by the Hart district— we are aggravated that we will need to spend time and effort in order to fight to keep what we have.
Some of those who plan to circulate the petition are doing so out of a sincere desire to help the children of Canyon Country. I applaud the sentiment, but it could be redirected to eliminating an effort that poses real threats to our children— the Transit Mixed mine! If you will circulate a petition against this outrage, you will be joining the near-unanimous voice in this valley trying to save our children from a very real threat.
The Hart and Saugus boards are not a threat to our children. Let us just stop and think— “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”
Ed Colley is a Canyon Country resident with six children, four of whom are school-aged .
