As an educator I feel glad when I hear our presidential candidates vying for the title of “Champion of Education.
” It is nice to know that whoever wins the election is going to be on my side.
The large budget surplus has enabled these candidates to emit previously unheard-of campaign rhetoric. It has been exciting to share in the educational possibilities these candidates have articulated. However, it appears that a big part of the educational battle between the candidates is the way each vows to prove he is a better education president by giving more tests to hold us teachers “accountable.” I was doing fine until we got to that point. That disturbs me for two reasons:
1. Besides putting in my 30 hours per week in the classroom, I am already putting in at least another 20, and usually 30 hours (sometimes 40) of my own time to try to bring my urban children up out of the 19th percentile (and that was an increase over last year!). But my class time is precious. As it is, my students are only seated in the classroom for about 900 hours per year. I already spend about 15 of those precious hours directly administering California’s Stanford 9, leaving me only about 885 hours for actual instruction. Please don’t take away any more of my precious instructional time.
2. It is popular for politicians, including Bush and Gore, to place contrived meaning on tests. Test scores have the appearance of a bottom line. Yet if you pin down any reputable researcher, s/he will water down any claims that any normative test, such as the Stanford 9 developed by Harcourt, is a valid measure of “classroom learning.” A Harcourt researcher might claim their product is “the best,” but that dodges the question. Test scores do not definitively measure teacher effectiveness.
The metaphor that underlies the belief that teachers are accountable for test scores is a translation of what works in business. In education? Test scores are supposedly our “product.” However, the “material” we are given for “production” lacks any quality control. How “raw” or “ un-raw ” the material may be when it comes to us is anybody’s guess. Therefore, belief in the factory metaphor for education holds teachers accountable for somebody else’s preproduction, without any system of accountability for the other parties. Such a practice is unheard of in business.
In education, determining “rawness” would be highly correlated with the socioeconomic status of parents, i.e., parents’ ability to pre-wire children’s brains to be receptive to the mainstream-intensive curriculum we teachers deliver. Usually, such ability comes when parents have had some success going through the “system” and know what is required on their part to ensure success. I ask which groups of parents perennially produce children with high test scores, and vice versa?
Since it is impossible to determine how “raw” or “ un-raw ” our students’ brains are when they come to the classroom, there is no way to accurately determine how much teacher competenee is reflected in test scores. Thererore, test scores are not a “bottom line” for anything. They provide nothing more than generalized indicators of how students are doing, and where parents and teachers need to focus in order to benefit each child the most, which is what tests were intended to do from the start.
If our candidates want to institute a meaningful program of accountability that transcends rhetoric, then let’s hold parents accountable for their knowledge and use of the mainstream cultural values that drive education (good luck with that one!) and let’s hold teachers accountable for their competence in using the delivery tools available to them, such as specialized training, advanced degrees, national board certification and peer reviews.
But please do not dump more politically contrived panaceas, (such as more tests), on us teachers. Just pay us what we deserve as highly skilled professionals, hold us accountable for how well we use the tools available to us, help parents to do their job, and get out of our way while we do our job, working hand in hand with parents.
Davy McClay is a Santa Clarita resident and teacher at Valerio Elementary in Van Nuys.
