Several weeks ago, Vice President Al Gore announced his plan for universal access to health insurance.
His plan is based on a dual strategy of rewarding states for implementing the Child Health Insurance Program (enacted as part of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 to provide states the opportunity to design meaningful health insurance coverage for children), and providing a refundable tax credit to help adults buy health insurance in private markets.
Ernie Tichenor
Those Damn Democrats
Not to be outdone, Gore’s challenger for the Democratic presidential nomination, former senator and basketball star Bill Bradley, has also proposed a plan for universal coverage, which actually replaces both Medicaid and CHIP with a system of premium subsidies and tax credits for the purchase of private health insurance by the poor and the uninsured.
It’s striking that both candidates have embraced the central element of health care reform advocated by the New Democrats: universal insurance bought through purchasing alliances, with government subsidizing the premiums through the tax system for those in need. Both candidates decisively broke with the old liberal alternatives of expanding government-provided or -controlled health coverage, or creating a Canadian-style nationalized insurance system. While both proposals deserve honorable mention for creativity and originality, I believe Bradley’s is the more interesting.
Bradley’s proposal would require all children to be covered by health insurance from birth. He would allow parents to enroll their kids in their own plan but would have federal backup for the rest.
He would also allow adults to enroll in the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program and provide a mix of tax credits and deductions to help families afford it.
Bradley deserves kudos for separating health insurance from employment. We will never have a market-driven health care system as long as employers make health care decisions for employees. Workers must be able to choose health care plans and keep them even when changing jobs. Bradley sensibly proposes that workers be allowed to purchase health insurance, independent of their employers, under a system of tax credits and deductions to help them afford it.
Bradley should also be commended for proposing to replace Medicaid with a private system that would allow Medicaid recipients to join the mainstream of society by participating in the private health insurance market, just like everybody else. Medicaid is a failure by any measure that counts. Eliminating the bureaucratic structure is one of the best things we could do.
However, I’ve got some major problems with a couple of other Bradley ideas. The first is his desire to make the raising of children a federal responsibility. He states that “because our children are our national future, their health care must be a federal responsibility.” This is a startlingly arrogant notion that could be easily expanded to include housing, diet, clothing, exercise and every other aspect of child rearing. America’s parents don’t need Washington telling them how to raise their kids.
A federal mandate requiring parents to cover their kids is an affront to families. I don’t believe parents purposely withhold insurance coverage from children. Those without coverage simply cannot afford the expense. Making coverage more affordable for these families should be enough, without resorting to the federal policing powers Bradley would use.
The second Bradley idea I have trouble with is the notion of putting everyone into the federal employees program, FEHBP. Although purchasing insurance independent of the employer is a good idea, FEHBP should not be the only vehicle to accomplish that. While FEHBP offers a variety of enrollment options, they all have to meet the same federal standards, which include ever-richer benefits and ever-higher costs. Some people might prefer to have a lower-cost plan and fund additional health care needs with either a medical savings account or other noninsurance methods. But the federal employees unions don’t appear to be interested in this kind of flexibility.
Another problem with the FEHBP is that it requires fee-for-service plans to charge the same premium regardless of location. This means federal workers in a low-cost area like Boise, Idaho, subsidize the care of workers in Los Angeles, even though health care costs half as much and federal wages are lower in Boise.
Even the Medicare program recognizes the importance of geographic differences in health care costs. The Medicare Part A payment rates for private health plans in a single state, such as New York, vary by as much as $250 per month depending on the county one lives in.
FEHBP also requires traditional insurance companies ( non-HMOs ) to be available in all 50 states if the companies want to be part of the program. This makes it impossible for smaller, regional companies to participate, even if they provide better services for less cost. It is a giveaway to a handful of giant national insurance companies (talk about corporate welfare). Curiously, this same requirement does not apply to HMOs that participate in FEHBP.
There are many other ways for working people to come together to purchase coverage outside of the employment system. Labor unions, credit unions, banks, social clubs, churches and homeowners associations all make for perfectly good pooling mechanisms that can respond to the needs of the membership without cramming everyone into a gigantic federal program.
Finally, I think Bradley and Gore should be commended for raising the issue of reform when Republicans and Democrats are running for cover on the issue. Both candidates offer an implicit challenge to Republican front-runner George W. Bush, who has said nothing on the issue, and whose own state of Texas has been slow to take advantage of existing federal incentives to cover uninsured children.
Both the Gore and Bradley proposals are important and will hopefully re-energize the health care debate around the country. Bradley, in particular, has shown courage and originality in his ideas, which is all too rare in politics. He would make an excellent running mate for Al Gore.
Ernie Tichenor is a member of the board of trustees at College of the Canyons. “Those Damn Democrats” appears Tuesdays, and rotates among several local Democrats.
