We the People through our city government are being asked to dive into a business deal involving a big retailer and a big developer. The developer and editors of this newspaper are trying to push us into promising $20 million of future sales tax revenues to pay for the retailer's new store.
The sales taxes we are to turn over would come not just from the new store but also from purchases made at all the other stores in the mall. We are told the $20 million would come only from the increased tax collections, as though sales at the mall would not grow at all without the big retailer.
We can't blame the developer for trying to extract the $20 million from the public treasury. Our economic philosophy — Capitalism — is based on the observation that private pursuit of profits leads to the common good.
Corporate managers are supposed to be greedy. They and their investors don't care whether those profits come from consumers or taxpayers.
We should fault ourselves, however, if we let our City Council go along with this. We would be violating the principles of our economic philosophy.
"The Free Market" means free of government interference. It means that buyers (or renters) of retail space should negotiate freely with suppliers of that space to decide where they will locate and how much they will pay.
As citizens who value job opportunities from a growing economy we are sometimes tempted to make exceptions to this principle. However, we also strongly believe in equal opportunity to participate in the economy. That means, in this case, that what the government offers one retailer, it should offer all others.
Is the City Council prepared to kick back future sales tax revenue for anyone who wants to open a store in this valley? If jobs are what we want, maybe half a million dollars to 40 smaller shops may do more for growth.
Under capitalism as we are taught in schools, the common good is better served when governments worry about defense, education, infrastructure, the environment and public health. We learned in the last century that protecting competition should be added to these responsibilities. For the most part, the remainder of the economic decisions should be left to consumers, investors and private businesses.
In a democracy, the majority can always decide to involve the government in the private economy. Wage and price controls in wartime, public works programs in a depression and 90-day cooling-off periods during major work stoppages are examples of this.
In the case of the developer and the retailer, we are urged to suspend the general rules for some extra economic benefits. Our democratic principles are much more important than the economic ones, so if the majority opinion guides our representatives to go ahead with this deal, it is appropriate.
The decision, then, becomes a political one because government is asked to become a party to an economic transaction it typically would leave to private interests. Here are four more points to consider in this political decision:
1. Our representatives do not always respond to our collective wishes. Hefty distribution of dollars to local politicians gives the developer disproportionate influence.
2. Any analysis or other economic data provided by the developer to justify the city's involvement might not be unbiased.
3. Our local newspaper does not have a tradition of in-depth investigative reporting on issues involving the developer.
4. Finally, consider the negotiating strength of the three parties to this deal. The retailer has other location opportunities for new stores.
If another city will give them more than $20 million they can threaten to go there. On the other hand, the city can try to find other retailers who will locate here without demanding $20 million in subsidies. The party that ought to be in the weakest position is the third one, the developer. They can't move the real estate.
You would think, then, that with the most to gain or lose in the deal, the developer would be stuck with having to come up with the $20 million.
That would be true except for Point No. 1. If We the People allow it.
* * *
Roger Velasquez is a Saugus resident. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
