Until March 24, the people of Jonesboro, Ark., were living pretty typical lives. But in the blink of an eye, their lives would be changed forever. Four girls and one heroic teacher were brutally gunned down in a scene that many observers likened to images of war-torn Bosnia. Two boys — ages 11 and 13 — were taken into custody as the primary suspects in this bloody rampage.
Closer to home, a 15-year-old Ventura boy, eager to earn the respect of other gang members, shot a 14-year-old boy to death; and four Riverside teens, ages 13 to 16, have been charged with beating and stabbing a man to death during a robbery.
The pain and horror of these shocking incidents have left Californians stunned and wondering out loud: What is being done to stop this madness?
There are two schools of thought on this subject — prevention and punishment — with proponents from both camps trying to persuade us they have all the answers. The fact is, this is a complex issue and both approaches merit our attention.
Effectively addressing the issue of juvenile violence holds the greatest potential for reducing future crime rates. The prevention of juvenile violence, in the broadest sense, is the responsibility of parents, teachers, coaches, churches and others that collectively make up a child's environment. If we can reach our youth before they enter the juvenile justice system, we can save lives, as well as valuable resources. But sometimes they can't be reached.
The horrible incidents of juvenile violence that we see on TV and read about in the newspaper are committed by youths who are beyond the reach of prevention offers. Not only do they bring into focus the epidemic of juvenile violence that has beset our communities, they also raise serious questions about the efficiency of our juvenile justice system.
One of the biggest problems is that our juvenile justice system is caught in a time warp. The softer philosophies that guided punishment in the 1960s and '70s are still being championed by liberal soft-on-crime legislators today. Treating violent juvenile offenders with kid gloves is not the answer.
Many juvenile advocates oppose tough sentences for teen and pre-teen offenders. But we are not talking about the girl who gets collared for shoplifting, or the boy who gets busted for fist-fighting. We are talking about a new breed of young offenders — violent rapists, carjackers and ruthless killers. These are hardened juveniles with no respect for human life and utter contempt for the law. With rare exception, they are beyond redemption and they must be dealt with accordingly.
Mayor Richard Riordan of Los Angeles perhaps said it best, "Our juvenile system simply does not work. In the current system all juveniles — serious offenders, first-time offenders and minor offenders — are basically treated the same. ... Juvenile courts were not designed for youths who commit serious and violent crime — gang murderers, rapists and carjackers. Keeping the more serious and violent offenders in the juvenile courts drains scarce resources that are best spent on children who can be turned around."
There is currently an effort under the Dome that would go a long way toward changing the status quo. A group of Republican legislators has introduced Assembly Bill 1735. Titled the Gang Violence and Juvenile Crime Protection Act of 1998, this measure would increase penalties so the punishment "fits the crime." Unfortunately, the liberal soft-on-crime legislators — staunch defenders of the status quo — recently killed an identical measure in the Senate. That portends for the future of Assembly Bill 1735, but hope is not lost.
While there is much to be said for trying to rehabilitate young offenders — everyone wants them to become responsible, law-abiding citizens — a line must be drawn when a child turns violent and rapes or terrorizes or murders. In such cases, rehabilitation must take a back seat to public safety.
* * *
Cameron Smyth is deputy chief of staff for state Sen. Pete Knight. "Do the Right Thing" appears Mondays, and rotates among several local Republicans.
