Do you believe in Santa Claus? One Christmas Eve, I found myself defending the jolly old gentleman, except that he wasn’t so jolly. Instead of out delivering toys to the children of the world, Santa was in court on trial, as he had been sued by the teen-agers of our neighborhood. The plaintiffs sought a declaratory judgment that St. Nick didn’t exist.
Although a bankruptcy attorney by trade, somehow I had been appointed to represent Santa, even though I no longer believed in the old man myself. The plaintiffs’ attorney was Ben, the precocious teen-ager who lives next door to my family. The jury was composed of the youngest children on our block, including my ingenuous daughter and son.
Ben began his case-in-chief by calling the teen-age plaintiffs as percipient witnesses. The jury heard testimony that each had been nice since the day he or she was born, and yet in recent years had inexplicably not obtained the tattoos or assault rifles they had requested from Santa. It turned out that one of the plaintiffs also worked at Target. While on the stand, she swore that she had sold toys to parents on our block that had later been found on Christmas morning in children’s stockings hung by fireplaces. I could think of no evidentiary objections to make during their testimony, and accepted their stories as true. As such, much to Santa’s dismay, I sat mute.
Ben then introduced evidence that FAA regulations would require reindeer to wear diapers if they could indeed fly, that the defendant was too fat to crawl down the gas fireplace chimneys in our neighborhood, that his toy workshop allegedly situated at the North Pole was not on any globe, and that none of his elves were listed on the “People Finder” on Yahoo!
By this time, the jury was giving me the look children give their father when they are told that doing their homework is better for them than watching television. As such, I sensed that it was time to call Santa to the witness stand.
I began my presentation to the jury by asking Santa, “Isn’t it true that your reindeer do wear diapers when they are flying?”
“Objection!” shouted Ben. “It’s a leading question. It also assumes facts not in evidence. It hasn’t been established that Santa owns any reindeer.”
“Sustained!” clamored the jury. (It was at this point that I belatedly realized that there was no judge in this court.)
I then asked Santa if one of the plaintiffs had once admitted to him while sitting on his lap that she had seen his reindeer flying.
“Objection, hearsay!” cried Ben.
I knew this out-of-court statement was an exception to the hearsay rule, but before I could remember which one, the jury again clamored, “Sustained!”
I could see that Santa was getting flustered with all these evidentiary objections and my inability to deal with same. I decided to try a different tack. I asked my client, “Isn’t it true that your Christmas list delineates every child as being either naughty or nice?”
“Objection, best evidence rule!” exclaimed Ben. “The best evidence of who has been designated as naughty or nice is this purported Christmas list itself. The defendant must introduce it into evidence before this court.”
I sat dumbfounded.
“Sustained!” giggled the jury.
I was mystified; how did a young teen-age boy know about the best evidence rule?
I inquired of Santa where the list was, and he testified that it was in the possession of his elves.
“But don’t you have custody and control over it?” interrupted Ben.
“Well yes,” said Santa, “I edit it with pen and quill myself all year, but I don’t know which elf has it at the present time.”
“Then we’ll just have to subpoena all the elves!” roared Ben.
Although I countered that the witness fee the plaintiffs would have to pay the elves (mileage from the North Pole) was a sum much greater than their respective allowances, I sensed that no one was listening to me anymore. The defense rested.
While Santa awaited the jury’s verdict, I tried to encourage my client by pointing out that like me, most of the jury probably wanted to believe in Santa Claus, even if they didn’t any longer. In reply, Santa asked: “Where did you go to law school?” Luckily, the jury filed back into the courtroom before I was forced to betray my alma mater.
All eyes turned to the jury. After getting a nod of approval from all the other children, my daughter rose and began to recite, “We the jury...”
And then I awoke. It was late Christmas Eve, just before midnight. Dawn was still far away. Not a creature was stirring, not even my two would-be jurors. My representation of Santa must have been a dream, and a harrowing one at that. My wife was asleep, so I crept to the cupboard where the stocking stuffers were hidden, and took them downstairs to perform the duties expected of me every Christmas Eve. As I tiptoed, I recalled that seminal Christmas in my youth when I stopped believing in Santa Claus. I had failed to get the big present I wanted, and upon reflection realized that the physical evidence of Santa’s existence didn’t warrant my further belief in him. Still upset over my performance at Santa’s trial, I wistfully reproached myself for not having taken a more existential stance in my life in the years since that day, and pondered whether we’d all be better off retaining more whimsy and magic in our lives.
When I reached the bottom of my stairs, I lit the Christmas tree. As I was warmed by its glow, I slowly swooned as my thoughts returned to that Christmas long ago where I lost my credulity. I turned to the fireplace, and was surprised to see that next to the kids’ stockings hung on the mantle were the rare Beanie Babies that I had been unable to find despite searching all over town. I guessed that earlier in the evening my wife had preceded me to this spot, but I was confounded by her failure to stuff the kids’ stockings, too. Why hadn’t she informed me that she had found the Beanie Babies each of the kids so desperately wanted?
As I struggled with this question, I happened to notice what had been left on the mantle next to my Christmas stocking: A textbook on Evidence.
Wesley H. Avery is a Los Angeles attorney who resides in Valencia. He also serves as a Judge Pro Tempore of the Los Angeles County Municipal Court in Newhall.
