Local activist John Steffen is taking on the city of Santa Clarita in U.S. District Court Monday in another skirmish in the long war between free speech and the powers that fight it.
It's not student protesters squaring off against government tanks, but it's still the little guy against big government; the average citizen exercising his right to criticize elected officials.
The old adage says, "I may not like what you say, but I'll defend your right to say it." John Steffen's voice may not be a popular one, but it nonetheless deserves to be heard, and that's why he's going to court.
The litigation stems from an incident in April, when Steffen addressed the City Council during its public participation session.
He tried to criticize incumbent Jo Anne Darcy, saying she ran a dirty re-election campaign. What Steffen referred to is the now-infamous "hit piece" that attacked candidate Marsha McLean and Councilwoman Jill Klajic.
It was one of two mailers published by an elusive political action committee two weeks before the election and financed in part by a $5,000 donation from Darcy. The charter council member maintains she knew nothing of the group's plans for mudslinging.
But Steffen didn't get far in his criticisms.
Within 30 seconds of speaking, Mayor Jan Heidt interrupted Steffen and asked him to keep his remarks "at a less personal level."
Steffen refused, saying he had a constitutional right to criticize Darcy. He continued speaking, but when he again commented on Darcy, Heidt cut him off, asking a sheriff's lieutenant to escort him from the podium.
Steffen took his seat, ending what could have been laughed off as a comical exchange between a city's mayor and one of the town's more confrontational citizens.
It's easy to dismiss John Steffen as a retiree who spends too much time at city meetings — and he does have a history of butting heads with local officials.
But to brush off the incident as the rantings of a paranoid gadfly is wrong.
John Steffen may be a thorn in the city's side, but he still has a right to address the City Council, regardless of whether they agree with what he's saying.
Disagreement is allowed, censorship is not.
Heidt maintains her aim was to keep order in the meeting and when Steffen's voice raised to a high pitch, she felt letting him continue would disrupt the council session. That's a lame excuse. A raised voice is not a threat to the process of government.
Will a sign be installed in council chambers instructing speakers to deliver their message in a deadpan monotone?
Heidt also says Steffen was given the allotted three minutes allowed all speakers. That's not true. Steffen was short-changed by 16 seconds when he was cut off by the mayor.
I'm sorry to see the matter go to court — lawsuits are ugly and time-consuming — but Steffen's is necessary. His rights were violated. And if the City Council can step on his toes, what's to keep them from making it a habit?
Without Steffen taking the matter to court, nothing.
This won't be a shot heard 'round the world in the fight for free speech, but hopefully its echoes will ring in the heads of future mayors when a vocal critic takes the podium at council meetings to come.
* * *
Eric Harnish is the assistant managing editor of The Signal. His commentary appears on Fridays.
