It is humorous to me how art imitates life..On Sunday, March 7, the Fox Network aired a new episode of "The X-Files" with an engaging and humorous plot that struck close to home. Without giving away the ending if you have the episode on tape, the basic premise was about a gated community that had created a demon/monster that was programmed to murder any residents who did not follow the strict CC&R's.
While this might seem like a governing board's dream, homeowners were actually forced into a phony kind of neighborliness with new residents in order to keep mayhem away from their doors. Knowing many folks in the entertainment biz live in the SCV, I can't help but wonder if there was a bit of specific satire aimed at our community.
There has been spirited debate within the SCV about the benefits and detriments of HOA's off and on since we moved here nearly three years ago. The online Tell It to The-Signal.com has allowed for this debate to burn like wildfire periodically since it debuted last summer, so I thought I would offer my ambivalent views on the subject.
First, let me give you my bona fides on the subject. My family lives in a homeowners association. This particular HOA does not seem to be extremely aggressive about enforcement of CC&R's, but they are no sluggards, either. While I do think that some of the rules are silly, the HOA does take excellent care in maintenance of our community amenities. So I think, like most people, if the benefits (well-maintained amenities) outweigh silly rules (don't leave your portable basketball hoops out overnight) I will grin and bear it and cheerfully comply.
In the community at large, at least among those who have an opinion, a computer and a modem, there seem to be two major segments. The first are those who do not live in HOA's but would like the city to enact and enforce CC&R-like ordinances in their neighborhoods. Among these folks there seems to be a particular issue with the parking of recreational vehicles; the larger the more irking.
The second segment of modem riders are those folks who do live in an HOA and feel like their Bill of Rights freedoms are being infringed by not being able to paint their house purple. Now of course these folks don't really want to paint their house purple, but I suspect they may have an RV in storage. These folks note quite correctly that HOA's have draconian powers over homeowners should they choose to pursue them. Who is right and who is wrong?
The truth, I think, lies somewhere in the middle. HOA's and CC&R's are merely a codification of what might be called a protection of the community interest, but as usual everything rises or falls in application. Let's take, for example, an HOA rule and see how they can be applied in a gentle fashion.
Since this seems to be the hot button, let's talk about the parking of RV's and boats on HOA property. This practice is strictly forbidden, but sanity in application allows the interests of the neighbors to be protected. On our cul de sac my next-door neighbor had purchased a new boat, and was selling his old boat. Prior to selling his old boat, my neighbor determined that some major work needed to be done. Being an engineer and thus handy with tools, my neighbor did the work on the boat in his driveway over a period of about three weekends.
This did not cause a big dislocation in the neighborhood. Prior to starting work my neighbor explained to all the cul de sac dwellers that he was going to be working on the boat for an extended period of time and it would be much easier to not have to move it back and forth to the storage yard. We all indulged this reasonable request, and no complaints were filed with the HOA. Our neighbor, to protect the rest of us, finished the work as quickly as possible and sold the boat.
So it would appear that the bottom line of the rules and regulations and their application is the protection of your neighbors. This seems a bold appeal, since a certain guy said nearly 2,000 years ago that loving your neighbors as yourselves was the second greatest commandment, and He's got a lot of people going to church every Sunday.
So when you park that RV, even if you don't live in an HOA, you should stop and think: Is this protecting the interests of my neighbors?
Or do they need to summon up a demon?
Tim Myers is a Santa Clarita resident. His column appears occasionally.
