But first, a little background on my standards for a preferred City Council member. First, the candidate must be heavily involved in activities for the betterment of the city of Santa Clarita and the entire SCV, not only participating in those events where many people go to be seen or belonging to committees where regular meetings are held but little else is done, but also dirtying their hands in the planning and followup, and putting their reputations on the line if things go sour. There are probably less than 200 people in our community who meet this requirement and I am here to tell you that I personally don’t qualify.
Based upon this standard, in my opinion (and other candidates can feel free to protest my assessment) there are only three candidates who pass the first standard. Those three are Marsha McLean, Cameron Smyth and Bob Kellar.
Now, on to the second standard. This standard is even more subjective. The requirement is that the election of the candidate will provide the greatest benefit to the community as a whole. With respect to this standard, the best candidate in my opinion by far is Marsha McLean.
Why Marsha McLean? For good or ill, there is a segment of our community who is anti-growth , but who care deeply about the community and are substantial assets in weaving its rich tapestry. Rightly or wrongly, unless someone is elected who is seen as sympathetic to this group’s point of view, they will divorce themselves from the political process, and rather than participating in the development of a compromise solution that is best for the community as a whole, they will become recalcitrant and dig in, making the other side, particularly the powers at the county level who are having such an impact on the greater SCV, also more recalcitrant and immovable.
This escalation will be a disservice to the community I love. Therefore I think it is best to vote for Marsha McLean or someone like her in order to achieve some sense of balance. Rightly or wrongly, the probable election of Kellar and Smyth will almost certainly result in the complete alienation of this segment whose views should be heard, slamming the door for a long period on the hope of building a consensus for our future.
But Marsha still has to pass a third test. This I was sure that I was not going to support Cameron Smyth’s second bid for a City Council seat.
Before March 17, 2000.
Before that date I could reel off all the reasons why one shouldn’t vote for Cameron Smyth. He has prep school good looks and a slim frame, neither of which I possess. He draws a government paycheck from state Sen. Pete Knight, who has probably done more than any other single individual to turn me into a RINO (“Republican in Name Only”). He is one of the anointed candidates of the SClarita “establishment,” an august and fine group of citizens I can only criticize for an appearance of not liking to hear people who disagree. Cameron, rightly or wrongly, has the image of being too closely aligned with developers, construction interests and the conservative core of the local Republican Party. I have to confess that I really thought that the election of Cameron Smyth to the council would just be more of the same; a continued rubber stamp for the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors and their somewhat disingenuous approval of developments outside of the SClarita city limits.
But all that changed on March 17, when Cameron Smyth took the time to visit two of Mrs. Linda Eveleth’s school-to-career classes at Sierra Vista Junior High School, and I took the time to get to know Cameron Smyth.
When Mrs. Eveleth, my favorite teacher in the SCV, sent me an e-mail to tell me that Mr. Smyth, in honor of a high school friendship with one of her grown children, had consented to take time away from his job in Sen. Knight’s office and a council campaign that had only 25 days to run to visit her classes, I was quite impressed. None of the 50 junior high students Cameron would visit with that day were registered voters, and based on past voting patterns, it was likely that only eight to 10 of their parents would vote in the upcoming council election. And yet, I was impressed that Cameron felt that it was important enough to spend his time with this integral part of the SClarita community.
And an impact he had. The students sat straight and attentive as Cameron shared with them his experiences on the Hart football team, his college experience at UC Davis, and his work in Sen. Knight’s office. Cameron does not parrot the tired truisms and excuses of the “establishment.” Instead, he is very much his own man with his own unique view and vision for SClarita. The best part by far, however, was when he got the students to open up and share their concerns about our city and how to improve it.
And you would be surprised to know that they have the same concerns as the grown-ups . While there were a few obligatory “teens need a place to hang out,” most of the input was quite mature, and included familiar concerns about increased park space, traffic circulation and school overcrowding. When Cameron asked these youngsters, some of whom are within 36 months of obtaining the much-anticipated driver’s license, whether restrictions on the driving of 16- to 18-year-olds were a good idea, almost all agreed, articulating mature reasons for the restrictions, including lack of experience, a feeling of invulnerability, and a need to “show off” and take chances in front of their friends. Cameron presided over it all with a grace and polish that belied his youth.
During this two-hour period it hit me why it is important that Cameron Smyth serve on the SClarita City Council. Big things are happening in the SCV, and leadership in the next few years will be critical. The right people at the helm of the city will make the difference between the SCV becoming the jewel of Southern California and taking its place at the lead of great suburban cities or just muddling through as a quirky place where council members hurl paperweights at each other. Like it or not, Cameron Smyth is the next type of leader needed in the evolution of our city, since he will have the polish, charisma and executive presence to represent our city well, whether before the Board of Supervisors trying to exert a sphere of influence, seeking sources of money for important infrastructure needs, or providing leadership on issues such as education for which the City Council is not directly responsible.
At the end of two hours I was completely won over, and I think that every other voter will be as well, as soon as they get to know Cameron Smyth rather than basing their views on what they think they know of him.
And I know Cameron Smyth now, because he took the time to visit Mrs. Eveleth’s classes. is the test of temperament. My ideal candidate must also be someone who wants to do right, and not just be right. Despite a long career in management consulting, I only recently learned that it is more important to build consensus and agreement rather than just prove you are right. In my business this arises in the context of client relations, and even though we may be exactly right, that doesn’t open up the customer’s checkbook. Neither does a constant tit-for-tat game of “who threw the paperweight” or “we don’t really like the nominee for the MTA board” get us one step closer to a solution to any problems or the achieving of any progress. My ideal candidate must have an even temperament and a sense of humor.
In order to test this standard, it was necessary for me to meet Marsha McLean, which I did at Danny’s Deli in Newhall on a sunny morning in March. While I gulped five cups of coffee and Mrs. McLean nursed a tea, she told me about the things she has done in the community, her continued involvement and her vision for the future. What was more important to me was what she didn’t say, and that was ignoble things about her opponents or current council members.
The thing that struck me most was a statement that people would be shocked at how often the council, even during the past year, which was marked by weird dissension, has voted 5-0 on many matters, including development within the city limits when standards that everyone can agree on were meant.
Mrs. McLean has a long history in the community of working with a lot of different people, and I have heard no complaints about her ability to get along and no accusations of seeking conflict merely for the sake of conflict.
So that is why I am going to cast one of my votes for Marsha McLean, and I hope that you will as well.
Stay tuned for my second endorsement.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
