A "controlled growth" (read no-growth) anonymous poster in the online Tell It to The-Signal.com , or the fourth century bear pit, as John Boston calls it, (just one growl after another!) throws down a challenge for someone, anyone, to list the benefits to the SCV of the Westridge and Newhall Ranch developments, which will eventually add 70,000 residents to the SClarita.
The poster then each day places posts in the Iranian Hostage format: "Day No. 1: No Response," etc., etc. Late on Day No. 2 a few people take up the challenge to talk about increased tax base, higher employment, TPC golf courses, etc. The "controlled growth" posters debunk each of these arguments in turn. Increased taxes will be absorbed to fund increased law enforcement, road and school needs. Most jobs created will be in the low-paying service sector. The TPC golf course will have such high fees that only a limited number of people in the SCV will be able to play.
I make a post offering to list the benefits in an ensuing column, and not to just go through the tried and trues of golf, taxes and jobs. This is my answer to the "controlled growth" folks. This is my list of benefits.
What is the optimal population of the SCV? I think that if you were to poll people who think that it is getting too large and crowded, you would almost always find that each one would believe the optimal population was the population when they moved here. Depending upon timing, it could be 50,000, 100,000, 150,000 etc., etc. This makes perfect sense emotionally since someone would probably not move here if they thought it was too crowded, congested, etc. Then of course comes the tendency to want to slam the gate or pull up the ladder behind you.
I grew up in a town with a population of 2,600 in a county with a population of 8,000. In the last 20 years the population of the town has actually decreased and the population of the county has only gone up 312. Talk about controlled growth! It must have been heaven on earth growing up in this small town!
No, it was not. As my father was fond of saying, 80 percent of the income of the county came from some governmental source; either agricultural department transfer payments, social security, welfare or the paycheck from a government job. This certainly applied to my family because my parents were both public school teachers. The lack of a varied employment and population base has its impacts.
What is the impact? As I tell friends and colleagues what it was like, I tell them to imagine a whole town full of guests for the Jerry Springer Show! Drug abuse in the high school was rampant! In my entire graduating high school class, only myself and three of my friends had not used some form of narcotic, and we abused alcohol. Teen pregnancy was also epidemic. A neighboring school one year could not field a junior varsity girls softball team since too many of the sophomore girls were "with child." And did I mention that we had rival youth gangs! The "Dopers" and the "Rednecks." I shouldn't have to describe them further. I would never raise my children in such an environment.
What then are the benefits of new people? People provide texture to an area, interest and good examples to children. When we lived in Texas we were in a boring, small suburb where everyone was either a CPA or some type of financial professional. My neighbor on one side worked for another national consulting firm while the neighbor on the other side worked as an auditor for the FDIC.
Here is a roster of my neighbors in the SCV: A defense engineer, a sports writer, two psychiatrists, a construction manager, a firefighter and a lobbyist. In my wider circle of friends I know an accident reconstruction engineer, who explains to me why the Newhall Pass congests in the morning mainly on sunny days, and a person who designs theme parks and has explained to me the theories behind good park design.
Every person who comes to the SCV has something wonderful to offer. A new bold voice in the church or temple choir, the ability to organize a school carnival that breaks all prior fund-raising records, a fine example as a coach to a soccer team, or children who are friends to everyone.
So what is my list of the benefits of Westridge and Newhall Ranch? It numbers 80,000, equal to the number of people that may arrive here, and the richness they will add to our lives.
What then is the optimal population for the SCV?
I will let you know when the last interesting person arrives!
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident. His column appears occasionally.
