I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. Santa Clarita is a great, if quirky community.
Where else could the deal surrounding the potential location of an upscale department store in the Valencia Town Center cause such controversy and discussion? A journalism professor once told me that you can accurately measure public opinion by the letters to the editor. He said that in a moderately sized community, such as SClarita, if one person was moved enough to take the time and trouble to write a letter to the editor on a particular issue,
at least 500-1 ,000 other people held a similar view. I don’t know how it works out with electronic discussion forums, but if you apply the same multiplier to Tell It to The-Signal.com , we can prove that everyone in the community has an opinion!
With the exception of me. I have concluded from all that I have read that I may be the only person in the entire SClarita who is wholly ambivalent on the issue of a Nordstrom. As I have said before, I can promise that I won’t shop there. I purchase my business suits from the Mens Wearhouse, my business casual wear from a famous catalog company in the Midwest that specializes in middle-aged “fat boy” clothing, and miscellaneous clothing, socks and underwear from the boxes and pick-over tables at Costco. My neutrality should give me credibility.
While some persons on one side of the issue see the shopping and service of a Nordstrom’s as the rounding out of their earthly existence, many of those against the Nordstrom subsidy are really against the building of a Nordstrom period, as they look wistfully on the construction of the upscale department store as the last proof that Santa Clarita is no longer a small town, and must take its place as a small city, and all the changes, both positive and negative, and the new challenges that this entails. This is the Nordstrom Rorschach test: Some seeing an affirmation of status and urbaneness; others seeing an end to a yearned-for era made more desirable by its passing.
I would ask, however, that we set aside the Rorschach and focus on the facts surrounding the Nordstrom subsidy, and yes folks, it is a subsidy, and debate the issues without the emotion and wistful yearning.
Fact No. 1: The city is not going to “give” Nordstrom $32 million to build a store at the Town Center. This amount will be funded by a loan and transfer of land, etc., by The Newhall Land and Farming Co. to Nordstrom.
Fact No. 2: The loan and additional up-front costs will be repaid, with interest, from a portion of the sales tax revenue generated by the Town Center over a period of several years. If the sales tax receipts are not high enough to service the loan and the interest costs, Newhall Land will be stuck. Therefore, in theory, the subsidy does not “cost” the city anything.
Fact No. 3: The building of a Nordstrom’s impact on other sales tax receipts in Santa Clarita is difficult to estimate and quantify. The city’s risk is that overall sales tax revenues will not increase, so that the redirection of sales tax revenues to repay the Nordstrom benefit will actually “cost” the city money. It is just as likely that overall sales tax revenues will increase, so the city would be money ahead.
Fact No. 4: Newhall Land is willing to take this risk not because they love grand piano music, or because they want to ruin life in the SCV, but because it is probable that a Nordstrom’s will attract other upscale retail tenants that will increase the rents and thus the value of the Town Center property, not to mention have a potential positive impact on the sale of tract homes in the area. They have analyzed the risks and believe it to be a sound business investment.
Fact No. 5: The package is a subsidy, since Nordstrom through Newhall Land is receiving something for free that they would otherwise have had to pay for if they decided to locate a store on the Town Center property.
Fact No. 6: Almost all major retailers (i.e. Home Depot and the Holy Grail of the Male shopping experience, Costco) have received similar benefit packages from the city.
Now with the facts in hand, we are ready to begin a debate in earnest. If you believe that corporate welfare is wrong and this is the place to draw a line in the sand, I can see your point. If you believe that the incremental tax revenue could not otherwise be obtained and are in favor of the subsidy, I can see your point.
But even though I will never shop there, let’s take the emotion out of the debate on Nordstrom!
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident. His column appears occasionally.
