While the Hart Board of Trustees this past week contemplated going to a three-track system in order to make space available for junior and senior high students due to the narrow failure of Measure S to garner the required two-thirds for approval, I am once again visiting the results of the election, unable to resist the urge to take advantage of my academic training and career experience to systematically analyze the precinct results (absentee ballots are not tracked in this way) and dissect all the available numbers.
Now, while some may place a curse of the cat people on me for dredging up the Measure S debate once again, I spent a lot of time analyzing these results so I am compelled to share. Also, since I broke down and analyzed results to the precinct level, it will serve to point Michele Buttelman in the right direction when and if she decides to go on her murderous rampage against the anti-S forces.
A few election facts as previously reported in The Mighty Signal: Measure S received a majority of the vote in each of the SCV’s component communities. Measure S failed to receive the required two-thirds support in the communities of Newhall, Castaic and Val Verde. Measure S received the required support by a comfortable margin in the communities of Canyon Country, Saugus, Valencia and Stevenson Ranch.
There were 56 precincts involved in the Measure S election. Measure S garnered at least 50 percent of the vote in each and every precinct in the SCV. Measure S garnered the required two-thirds support in 33 out of the 56 precincts and failed in 23 precincts.
The measure had the broadest support in Stevenson Ranch, where the Measure passed in both of the area’s precincts. Close behind was support in Valencia, where the measure achieved passage in 10 out of 12 precincts, and Saugus, 11 out of 14 precincts. While the measure passed in the community of Canyon Country, support was not as broad, with the measure achieving passage in seven out of 14 precincts. In Newhall, the measure garnered passage in only three out of nine precincts, and the measure failed in all five of the precincts in the Castaic/Val Verde communities.
Ironically, the highest support for Measure S came from those areas that will receive new schools due to mitigation agreements with developers, and possess newer schools now that are in less need of maintenance, including the areas surrounding La Mesa Junior High School, the Northbridge, Northbridge Pointe, Northpark and Summit areas of Valencia, the Mountainview area of Saugus, and Stevenson Ranch. Also ironically, the residents in these areas have paid large school fees on the front end of their home purchase. Many (including yours truly) are paying Mello-Roos tax loads that are amortizing debt that was used to fund school facility construction. Yet still, the folks in these areas that bothered to show up for the election were willing to take on an additional tax burden to benefit school facilities in the entire SCV.
Which precincts had the highest turnout? That honor would go to the precincts including the Old Orchard area of Valencia, an established neighborhood where the higher voter turnout succeeded in garnering the required two-thirds support. Other established neighborhoods that pitched in with high support were the areas around Newhall Elementary and the Granary Square area of Valencia. While these neighborhoods are established and would seem to have one of the better arguments of “make the developers pay” for increased school populations due to increased development, these folks also recognized the importance of the passage of the bond. High turnouts were also enjoyed in the Northbridge, Northbridge Pointe and Northpark areas of Valencia and the area of Saugus surrounding James Foster Elementary, which I would assert is due to the incredible efforts of the PTAs at Helmers, Northpark and James Foster elementary schools to get out the “Yes” vote.
Where did the measure receive its lowest support? Besides Castaic, where the highest “Yes” percentage was a narrow failure in the area surrounding Live Oak Elementary, the measure’s failure was also felt in older areas of Canyon Country and Newhall. So while Measure S opponents proclaim a great moral triumph, your “Victory” actually came in the tracts of Castaic and the precincts of east Canyon Country. Interestingly, when you look at the numbers overall, in those precincts passing Measure S average support was over 72 percent. In those precincts where the measure failed, average support was only 59 percent. One could theorize that we are really two communities within one with different ideas about education financing.
And I will address that issue more fully next week, when I suggest the dismantling of the Hart District and the redrawing of the school boundaries to more accurately reflect the views of the voting residents.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
