So the latest political controversy in the SCV has reached a watershed. Lynne Plambeck has convinced a Superior Court judge that she indeed can characterize herself as an “environmental water consultant” on the ballot for the Newhall County Water District board as she attempts to reclaim a seat lost in 1997 in the next election.
Let me say at the outset that from everything I have read and understand, Ms. Plambeck meets the legal requirements to list herself as a “water consultant.” She has shown to the satisfaction of an independent trier of fact that she spends at least 30 to 35 hours per week on water-related matters, and she had five sworn witnesses declare that they had consulted her on water matters. But this of course is not going to end the controversy.
What has everyone upset is what occurred in the last Castaic Lake Water Agency election. All of the candidates who are members of Ms. Plambeck’s “posse” that ran in that election lost, with the exception of Mr. Ed Dunn. Ed Dunn also listed himself as a “water consultant,” and squeaked by a narrow victory against the incumbent. Charges and countercharges were made in that situation, and the same will continue to occur in the current cycle.
Personally, even though I do not agree with the views of Ms. Plambeck and others of like mind, and will generally vote for their opponents every chance I get, I think that this controversy really points up the need to eliminate occupation designations from ballots, rather than any malicious or dishonest intent on her part.
Let me frame the issue this way. Anyone in the SCV who even reads The Signal once a month knows exactly where Ms. Plambeck is coming from politically. She and some other folks are seeking to control the water in the SCV in order to control growth. I don’t agree with that point of view, so I will not vote for them. Others agree with that point of view and they will vote for her. Majority rules.
The hangup is that there is a certain, unquantified portion of the electorate that bases most of their franchise decision on the ballot information each candidate submits. I know some of these people, so unfortunately my evidence is only anecdotal, but their profile seems to develop as a person who lives here, commutes to another city to work, does not subscribe to The Signal, and feels perfectly comfortable in making a decision in a local election based solely on what they read on the ballot. (I work with some of these people so they might actually look at one of my columns on The-Signal .Com to gauge my current level of dementia.) I will not attribute any bad motivation to Ms. Plambeck, but it would be tempting to anyone running for office to try to manipulate this group, and for the opposition to complain about said manipulation. The irony is that due to the profile of these individuals, this debate will also be invisible to them!
I look to my own occupation as an example. While I am certain that I would be protected from ever holding public office by a wise electorate, I could characterize myself in many ways if I thought I could gain some advantage.
I used to characterize myself as a tax consultant, but I stopped that because I am actually expert in a very narrow area of tax law. When I introduced myself as a tax consultant, people were prone to ask me a lot of personal tax questions, which I am not qualified to answer. Also, I spend more time coordinating the delivery of a variety of professional services, so the characterization of consulting executive was adopted as being more descriptive.
But since 30 to 35 hours per week is all that is required to support a ballot designation, there are a lot of other titles I could use.
I could be a Sleep Consultant. Actually I am very good at this since I can fall asleep in about 30 seconds any time of the day or night. Nancy would also say I could be a Snoring Consultant in tandem with the Sleep business. I couldn’t list myself as a newspaper columnist, since I don’t spend 30 to 35 hours working on this, as should be obvious by the general quality and coherence. Maybe I could be a Costco Consultant, since I think about how wonderful that place is all the time.
No, I think the best solution would be to eliminate ballot designations entirely. That way no one can complain that someone is trying to manipulate a less-than-educated electorate. And the folks who rely on that solely, maybe they will stop voting, but do we really want folks who base their entire decision on something they read on one piece of paper voting anyway?
We better go ask a Voting Consultant.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
