People accuse me of wearing rose-colored glasses. I have to admit that I’ve always believed I am one of the biggest optimists around. But that was before I read Joan Warden’s commentary in The Mighty Signal on Friday, Nov. 19.
Now this lady is an optimist! In the world in which I reside, people, businesses, churches, governments and schools all need to borrow money in order to acquire long-lived structures such as homes, office buildings and factories. Creditors loan this money in exchange for interest, and they will only loan the money on the belief that the principal and interest will be repaid in a timely manner.
Individuals and businesses pay the principal and interest from their future earnings, churches from pledges, which are made in advance, and schools and government pledge a dedicated stream of tax revenue in the form of a bond.
In Joan’s world, everybody can just pass the hat around and raise $250 million to build and renovate school infrastructure, no problem.
How is this done in Joan’s world? First, there are all these millionaires who live in the SCV who can kick in the money. I guess this is not so overly optimistic since Joan believes there must be at least 500 millionaires out there with a spare $500,000 in cash.
Unfortunately, in my world, all of the millionaires I know have almost all of their wealth tied up in the equity and working capital of their businesses, providing employment opportunities for many people and contributing mightily to the federal, state and local tax coffers, so they don’t have a lot of available cash.
Second, Joan believes corporations have excess cash to pony up toward school infrastructure, never minding that they are already subject to the same property taxes as a resident. In fact, in her world that are 12 corporations that must have about $21 million apiece that they could contribute to the schools. Unfortunately, in my world the few corporations that don’t have their cash tied up in necessary working capital to operate their business use excess cash to reward their loyal employees and to invest in R&D and other initiatives to provide greater opportunities in the future.
Third, in Joan’s world we can all pick up hammers and spend the morning raising a complete school from the ground to the sky, and then drink Coca-Cola and join hands and sing, “I’d like to teach the world to sing.” After all, Jimmy Carter builds about 1,000 houses a day for Habitat for Humanity in Joan’s world.
In my world, a Habitat for Humanity chapter can spend up to two years raising the money to pay for the materials and professional work necessary to build a very basic 1,500- to 2, 000-square-foot home. Also, the person who occupies the home is responsible for a mortgage, albeit a smaller one, on the new residence, not to mention that in my world schools must follow much more stringent building and maintenance requirements, which can pretty much preclude the use of any significant volunteer labor.
Fourth, in Joan’s world sales tax revenue is not available to school districts, but is used directly by cities, counties and the state to pay for a variety of programs. In my world a school district can only receive sales tax money indirectly, through largess from the state government. Also, in Joan’s world millions of dollars in tax revenue could be generated this year from sales taxes on Pokemon alone!
In my world, for $5 million in sales tax revenue to be generated from Pokemon this year, assuming the fiction of Joan’s world that all sales tax revenue could be diverted from paying for other government services such as police and fire protection and road building and maintenance, EVERY man, woman AND child in the SCV would have to spend $250 this year on Pokemon and every year on the ensuing toy crazes.
Assuming generously that one-third of the SCV is made up of children in the age range that buys Pokemon, that would be $750 per child per year. To generate the approximate $30 million per year that would be necessary to fund a debt required for school infrastructure, every child would need to buy $4,300 in toys per year— a much wiser way to spend our money rather than about $20 per person, tax deductible, to fund a school bond that will allow us to unlock state matching funds for education.
But I guess when it is all said and done, maybe I still do wear rose-colored glasses and am the biggest optimist I know. This is because in Joan’s world there are sales taxes, wealthy people and corporations with excess money, and hammers and nails to raise a school from the ground up.
But then I live in the real world.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
