In my last column I alluded to how I believed that people’s worry about the prevalence of crime, particularly violent crime, is not supported by the real numbers.
I wanted to make a very unscientific test of this theory, so I asked 10 colleagues— all of whom live outside of the SCV and would not have read the column published Dec. 5— the number of homicides they believed had occurred in cities with more than 100,000 in population within the first six months of 1999. (Each was adjured to immediately respond and not try to look the information up.) Each one of the individuals is a highly educated professional consultant and they would consider themselves well-informed people. I would agree with that assessment. Well, the results came in and the answers ranged all over the board with a high of 100,000!
If you will recall from last week’s column, the actual number was 3,293. Thus, there was an anecdotal belief that homicide was 33 times in excess of the actual number! How has crime invaded our sensibilities so much that it has obtained almost urban legend status as to its frequency even among those who could most easily determine the objective facts?
Obviously, news gathering and reporting organizations are a big part of the reason. Local newscasts have become little more than the crime blotter after weather and sports are taken out, with the cynical modern mantra of “If it bleeds, it leads!” becoming the byword of the news producer. There is also the fact that, because of their rarity, the media will report and report and report upon particularly heinous incidents like Columbine. As followup story after story is reported, good journalism requires inclusion of a summary of the original event, so I wonder if we begin to think subconsciously that the event is happening each and every time it is reported.
The entertainment media is also contributing. I love to watch three crime dramas: “NYPD Blue,” “Law and Order” and “Law and Order Special Victims Unit.” In the first, each weekly installment shows the male and female detectives of the 15th Precinct handle at least one and sometimes up to three homicides during an episode, which is staged as one or two days at the most. While the body count is not as high in the two other shows, at least one homicide is portrayed per week. What does this mean if you extrapolate the numbers as I am sure viewers like me subconsciously do?
I tried it. Let’s say a typical two days at the 15th precinct will have our detectives clearing at least one homicide. That means that 90 homicides will be committed within that precinct alone in a six-month period! This would account for 30 percent of the homicides actually committed in New York in the first six months of 1999! There are at least 102 precincts in the NYPD so the other 101 precincts are only handling two homicides per precinct in the first six months, or about 0.01 per day! You would think our favorites of the 15th squad could get a little help!
“Law and Order” and “Law and Order Special Victims Unit” handle a new homicide each week in New York City. So add another 56 to “NYPD Blue’s” total and the 15th squad, seven detectives at SVU and two additional detectives and a lieutenant are now handling half of the actual homicides in New York! To put it another way, extrapolating the other direction, 9,000 murders would have been committed in New York in the first six months of 1999, 30 times the actual total and three times the total for all large cities for the television shows to actually portray reality.
This exaggeration is not new! John Wesley Hardin was the most prolific gunslinger in 19th century Texas, killing 21 in his long career, but in a single recently viewed syndicated repeat of Bonanza from the ’60s, sweet young Joe Cartwright was forced to shoot four bad guys to death, 20 percent of Hardin’s lifetime total in just one episode!
I am not suggesting that television stations report nightly the accurate fact that over 3.5 million people in Los Angeles and 7.4 million people in New York were not the victim of a homicide today or that prime time television should be 95 percent filled with folks eating, sleeping and going to and from work. I do think that we can come to a realization of the real occurrence of crime and take control of our feelings.
In the third and final column in this series, with the help of Santa Clarita law enforcement personnel, we will explore what each of us can personally do to reduce crime even further, and retake the control of our feelings concerning this issue.
Tim Myers is a Valencia resident.
