School districts expect students to progress through each grade level within one school year. For the majority of students, this system seems to work.
What to do then, about the student who does not meet minimum standards to pass? For many of these students, this pattern repeats itself year after year.
Johnny can't read and what happens to him? He advances to the next grade level. It's called social promotion and for years it has been the practice of our public school system.
This practice of social promotion is about to change.
Three bills related to pupil promotion and retention were approved by the Legislature in late August. AB 1626 requires governing boards to adopt policy regarding the promotion and retention of pupils between specified grade levels.
AB 1639 requires school districts to offer students who have been retained intensive supplemental instruction and SB 1370 increases summer school funding for intensive supplemental instructional programs specified in AB 1639.
In plain English, these three bills give the school districts authority to retain any student who is not meeting minimum requirements and the money and additional instruction to help students who are in danger of failing.
School districts across the state are now scrambling to make these bills a policy. It seems easy, but the state is leaving the requirements for promotion and retention to each school district and there are many questions to answer. How many times can a student be held back? What about English language learners? Special Education children? None of these are addressed in the law.
Don Hughes, administrator for instructional services in the Newhall School District, is chairing an ad-hoc committee to address these very issues within his district. "We need to look at the whole child," said Hughes. "By giving each district the power to address the issues, it gives us more opportunity to look at each individual child."
The first priority for the committee is to establish a policy. Comprised of administrators, teachers and parents, the committee began by reviewing standards that are already in place and will draft a school board policy that reflects the district's position on student retention and promotion.
Test scores from the SAT 9 (an annual required state test) are a good indicator of students' progress in each grade level and will be one of many indicators that are used to identify students who are at risk. Subject areas to be considered, depending on grade level, were reading proficiency, language arts, writing samples and mathematics, concepts, application and computation.
Parents will play a key role in the retention and promotion policy. The law requires that parents be notified as early in the school year as practical if their child is in danger of being retained. One hundred and twenty hours of intervention (which is equivalent to four weeks of summer school) must be given to these at-risk children.
Hughes explained that for Newhall School District, which is on a year-round, multi-track calendar, intervention could come in the form of before- and after-school, Saturday and intersessions which could be scheduled in blocks so the students have some vacation time. English language learners and special education students will have other requirements to meet.
Once the committee has completed their draft, it is forwarded to district administrators, site council chairs and PTA presidents, as well as other school districts and their superintendents. "Other districts are going through this policy development and we are trying to be somewhat consistent for those students who move from one district to another," explained Hughes.
"We also need to stay in touch with the William S. Hart Union High School (District) as our students feed into those upper schools."
The draft is then sent to the school board for three readings before becoming policy. Once the policy is in place, each school begins the process of identifying at-risk students.
Intervention has always had a place in our school districts. The new state standards will be a measure to provide a more consistent intervention for all of our students.
There are many debates regarding retention and social promotion. Whatever side of the fence you may be on, the new policy will be a win-win situation for those students who need just a little more.
Patti Rasmussen is a Santa Clarita resident. Her education column appears Saturdays.
