There's trouble brewin' in Beantown.
I've read with great interest the quagmire in which the Boston Globe is finding itself, here-a-columnist gone, there-a-columnist about to go. Maybe. Depends on how our favorite kissin' cousins, gender and race, get along.
The recent troubles began when Globe columnist Patricia Smith resigned in early July. A finalist for this year's Pulitzer Prize, Smith admitted she made up quotations and people in four columns this year. A meeting with management sealed her fate.
This was not the first time Smith's work had been scrutinized; in 1986, as an editorial assistant at the Chicago Sun-Times, bosses barred her from writing for several months due to factual errors in reviewing an Elton John concert, of all the seemingly wacky things.
Smith said she attended the concert and there was never an official finding to the contrary. But the fact her press tickets were never picked up compounded suspicion she hadn't even said hello to the Yellow Brick Road.
Her personal albatross followed her east. As recently as 1995, questions popped up regarding the legitimacy of Smith's columns, but were never directly addressed because there had been similar accusations about the work of another Globe columnist, Mike Barnicle.
Only once Smith admitted she erred did she lay herself off. Barnicle is now in the hot seat, being caught in a big ol' whopper of an unfortunate situation.
Barnicle has been suspended after mentioning some jokes in his column, which were later discovered to closely resemble one-liners in George Carlin's 1997 best seller, "Brain Droppings."
Barnicle told editors he had never read Carlin's book; in fact, he got the material from two friends.
Try again, bub. Turns out Barnicle recommended Carlin's book on a television show two weeks prior to the column.
Well, Barnicle isn't going down without a fight. Though his bosses have asked for his resignation, he's not going gentle into that good night, refusing to step down and blasting his employer for disloyalty.
Woman columnist resigns. Man columnist does not. Hmmmm.
Ah, if only it could have been a matter of gender. Smith is black. Barnicle is white. How ya like them apples?
Is race definitely a factor in this delicate social dance? Apparently not for the bosses — black, white, male, female...they don't mind lightening their columnist load by cutting any quadrant. And guess what, there are plenty of people ready and willing to step in to take Smith or Barnicle's jobs. I know, I work with them.
And there's a lot of community support behind Barnicle. The Globe reported in the Aug. 8 edition of the paper there were 955 calls the day before, with the ratio running five to one in Barnicle's favor.
Hell no, he won't go, but maybe he should. An informant of mine has a relative who grew up with Barnicle and says he makes stuff up all the time. Interesting tidbit.
Though I as a journalist don't condone what either Smith or Barnicle did, it does underscore an angle of the big intellectual property debate.
Who doesn't always give props to the right person? How many times have you repeated a story, or a joke to someone, not having any idea who told you first? Just the other day, at this august publication, Mr. Santa Clarita Valley credited me with an idea for a don't-we-wish board game featuring Santa Clarita names and places in a Monopoly-like setting. Truth was, I told him about it, but my co-worker, Momma Chambers, came up with the idea. Maybe the chance to see my name in print in a non-byline form was too tempting to correct him. Or maybe I truly forgot who mentioned it first. Who knows.
The Boston snafu brings to mind another case of the flower of gender cross-pollinating with race.
Janet Cooke was a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist who admitted to making up a series about an 8-year-old heroin addict.
She was fired from her job at the Washington Post and disgraced from the hallowed halls of the fourth estate. I read in a Vanity Fair article a few years back she was working at a Michigan department store to make ends meet. She's black. She's a woman. Maybe Quentin Tarantino will cast her in his next film to boost her visibility level.
* * *
Nicole Campbell covers education for The Signal. Reporter's notebook is a rotating staff column that appears Mondays.
