After hearing horror story after horror story about people’s bad HMO experiences, I finally found out what all the ranting is about after spending one unfortunate evening in the urgent care unit of my HMO, where I waited (and waited) along with about two dozen other people to be seen by a health care worker.
Reporter's
Notebook
When I arrived a few weeks ago at my San Fernando Valley HMO (which will remain nameless in order to protect the incompetent), I walked past dozens of coughing, bleeding and sneezing patients lined up in the waiting room to the receptionist sitting by the window.
It was hard to get the attention of “Helen,” the receptionist, as I was obviously interrupting her while she was watching the end of a gushy romance movie that was on TV.
“What are you here for?” she barked at me. When I told her, she yawned, grabbed my card out of my hand and then spent about 10 minutes shuffling the 20 copies of about three dozen forms together. “Put the top copies of sheets A, B, C and D in slot 3, put the middle copies and section C in that basket over there and put the end copies in slot 325 in section A of the building. Your wait will be about 45 minutes.”
“Cool,” I thought to myself. “I’ll be home in time to see the end of ‘I Love Lucy.’”
That was at about 4:45 p.m.
As I looked for a place to sit in the waiting room, there were only two seats available. One was by “Typhoid Mary,” who had what appeared to be whooping cough and was careful to only cover her mouth three minutes after she was done coughing. The other seat was next to a couple, who appeared to not have anything that looked too contagious. Taking my chances, I decided to sit next to “Al” and “Betty.” As I sat there, I decided I may as well make the best of a bad situation and make light conversation with “Al,” who brought his wife in after she was in a car accident.
“Betty” had been bleeding from a gash above her eye for about an hour and a half before she was finally called in to be seen by one of the two doctors on duty. The staff was good enough to give her an ice pack while she waited.
After the first 60 minutes of my wait, “Helen,” who had been staring at the TV and yawning throughout the evening, got on her microphone (no sense in walking over to the waiting room. It would have taken too much energy) and announced, “The average wait is now about three hours because we’re unusually short-staffed right now.” Then she added, “And one of the two doctors on staff is leaving for the night.”
“Helen” ignored the grumbling and shrieks that came from the agitated patients in the room and switched off her microphone. She slumped back in her chair and stared at her nails.
Realizing I was in for the long haul, I decided I may as well read one of the two magazines from 1996 that was displayed on the table. I looked up, however, from the article I was reading in the magazine titled, “Why our HMOs are failing us,” when I heard moaning coming from the receptionist area. Oh, no! Had “Helen” chipped one of her nails?
No, the moaning was from a patient who shuffled in, half slumped over, who said that she had fallen earlier in the day and had injured her back and felt dizzy.
“Walk over to the emergency area across the hall. It’ll be a shorter wait,” “Helen” told the woman, who then shuffled back across the hallway, without any offer of a wheelchair or other assistance. A few minutes later, the woman shuffled back into urgent care. She had been rejected by the E.R. and was told to walk back.
As more and more patients started filing in, much to the agitation of “Helen,” the door from the care unit opened and out hobbled, literally, a man who had apparently either broken or sprained his ankle. He was given directions to walk to the X-Ray unit across the building, injured foot and all. (My boyfriend shared with me a similar story of having to hobble to X-Ray with a broken toe at the same facility several years ago).
As one man stood in line with his infant son, “Al” decided to give him a warning, “Your son will be a teen-ager before he gets out of here.”
The man took the hint and said he would come back the next day.
After three and a half hours had passed, I had read from cover to cover both magazines in the waiting room, listened to “Al’s” life story and the snoring of the man sitting next to me.
Finally, just when I was trying to remember what had brought me to urgent care in the first place, the big moment had arrived! My name was finally called! It was now 8:15 p.m.
I was led to an exam room where I waited (and waited some more) to be seen by a physician’s assistant. I knew things would be delayed after hearing the assistant yelling at a nurse in the hallway about losing a patient’s urine specimen. When he finally entered (at about 9 p.m.), he broke the bad news.
“Did you bring your chart in here? Do you know what happened to your chart?” He assured me that he would go about diligently trying to find it.
Maybe it’s by the other patient’s lost urine sample, I wanted to say.
He breezed back in at about 9:30 p.m., no chart in hand. “We had no luck with your chart. It’ll pop up somewhere. We’ll have to look later.”
After spending about 10 seconds looking in my ear, he re-confirmed my suspicions. I had an inner ear infection. He disappeared for another 30 minutes and finally re-appeared with a scribbled prescription for antibiotics.
“Make sure you take them all,” he warned. “Or you’ll end up back here.”
No need to say more. Not that bonding with the other patients in the waiting room wasn’t fun, but I can think of better ways to spend five hours of my time.
The threat of ending up back at that HMO is probably the main motivator for patients to stay well. I have since joined a gym, take daily vitamins and have cut out all unhealthy foods. Who says HMOs don’t contribute to the health and longevity of their patients?
Marci Wormser is a Signal business writer.
More "Reporter's Notebook" Columns
