My baby starts junior high next week.
The youngest of the fold, the last of the Rocks to be entrusted to the Hart district, is soon to become a noble Plainsman.
She’s really excited about starting seventh grade. Already she and her pals are showing off their new student ID cards and buzzing about rotating schedules. She’s in for some big surprises with all the independence offered in such an educational setting.
She’ll be studying new kinds of math, science, languages and government— the last being a most critical issue, given the questionable logic of the district in a hot issue facing junior high families. That would be uniforms.
You see, her school is one that requires uniforms; a legitimate approach to the elusive problem of potentially fatal fashion flaws. Wear pants too baggy and you could be beaten to a pulp before brunch. Wrong color scarf? Say hey to a flying fist or worse. I’m not going to visit the inner-city wail of “it couldn’t happen here” drive-by shootings, because we have the best law enforcement around.
No, the only victims in this uniform fracas are those being robbed by the district’s “ one-source ” uniform provider.
The dictum is handed down in the official handbooks given to new students: Experience has taught us that not all parents can agree with what constitutes ‘proper fit and style,’ which has created a need for this ‘single vendor’ provision as part of our uniform program. There. The district said it and it must be.
In other words, the district does not trust you.
We have gone from being parents supported by our educators to parents subjected to a ruling that the American Civil Liberties Union maintains is illegal.
Nowhere in the policy does it mention that the parents have the right to “opt out” of the uniforms, but the word on the parent grapevine is that Arroyo Seco Junior High, which is non-uniformed , is open for those wishing to dress individually. That would be fine, except for one thing. Enrollment at Arroyo Seco is closed. No opt-out option there. Hmm. For a publicly-funded district with many venues for publicity, that’s something that should be included in all their materials, but is mysteriously absent.
I don’t have a problem with the uniforms themselves and understand why the decision to require them was made. And I don’t want to drive my daughter across town— nothing against the school, this is a morning time crunch thing— so I’m happy with her attending Sierra Vista. But the single-source policy is completely in violation of the free enterprise system that we teach our children about in economics class.
For example, the uniform windbreakers required by the district cost $38. The exact same jacket by the exact same manufacturer is $20 at a major local department store. The comparisons are the same all the way down the required garments list. But if your child wears one of the competitors’ items to school, they will not be given the free and equal education that our government guarantees to every child.
Where does a district get off wielding that much power? In other words, the Hart district not only doesn’t trust you, but also don’t think the law applies to it.
It is appropriate to note that this is not the first time the Hart district considered itself above the law. Last December, the district’s lawyers (whose fees we, the taxpayers, paid) entered into a confidential settlement agreement with its insurer over earthquake damage at the Hart High School auditorium. The Signal filed a California Public Records Act letter demanding the settlement details, which were eventually revealed. The majority of feedback from the community supported the paper’s actions to hold the district responsible.
But without a bit of the spotlight, the district would have operated outside the parameters of the law. After an article was published in Saturday’s paper about a parent who stood up to the district and contacted the ACLU, the feedback started again.
Suddenly the community’s outrage shifted from the uniform store’s outrageous pricing and surly staff to the audacity of the district and its utter disregard for the families it allegedly serves. It certainly begs the questions: If you are a parent in the Hart district, how much are you willing to allow the district to tell you what is best, regardless of established laws? How much secrecy are you willing to accept? And of all public institutions, shouldn’t our school districts, which are responsible for teaching our children, be expected to operate within the governmental structure (i.e., laws) already in place?
It’s gone beyond a question of uniform prices and fully involves a lack of respect for parents and their rights. Just who is benefiting from these kinds of actions? It’s certainly not the families that the district is bound to serve.
Uniforms are a reasonable answer to a potentially dangerous school situation. But the district’s approach to protecting our children has shifted into holding the parents hostage— a condition no one should be forced to accept. And allowing a school district to operate outside the very laws they are teaching our children to uphold is the worst curriculum we can uphold.
Carol Rock is The Signal’s entertainment editor. Her column appears Thursdays.
