Alternative medicine, also known as complementary medicine (CAM) covers a wide range of healing philosophies, approaches and therapies. Generally, it is defined as those treatments and health-care practices not taught widely in medical schools, not generally used in hospitals, and not usually reimbursed by medical insurance companies.
Many therapies are termed “holistic” which means that the healthcare practitioner considers the “whole person,” including physical, mental, emotional and spiritual aspects. Numerous therapies are also known as “preventative,” meaning that the practitioner educates and treats the person to prevent health problems from arising, rather than treating symptoms after problems have occurred. People use these treatments and therapies in a variety of ways. Therapies are used alone (often referred to as alternative), in a combination with other alternative therapies, or in addition to conventional therapies (sometimes referred to as complementary).
Holistic Health Practitioner Tammy Asbrand, R.N., a Castaic resident, believes that many patients and families look to alternative medicine because they are not satisfied with standard medical treatments.
“One of the many frustrations they feel is that their allopathic (Western) physicians cannot find the origin of their condition— and they just get prescribed another medication on top of their existing medications,” said Asbrand, who also happens to be a Gerontologist Nurse Specialist at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital’s Adult Day Health Care facility.
Asbrand stated that such patients often feel like “they are just another number— and sometimes, when they ask about alternative treatments, the doctor shoots them down.”
Armed with two years of intense study in the science of acupuncture and herbalogy, along with the healing art of Qi Gong and Tai Chi, Asbrand said, “my pearls of wisdom have integrated my knowledge of alternative therapies with conventional medicine. This has enabled me to become a resource for my patients.”
Asbrand believes that combining both worlds, conventional and holistic therapies, is the key to achieving and maintaining the most important system of our body, the immune system.
“This system is the key focus for our future. We are losing foothold to the so-called “superbugs” even though the pharmaceutical industry is always creating new antibiotics. I feel there are many herbal supplements that can boost our immune systems, besides playing other positive roles in our health,” she said.
Supplements
You cannot watch TV, listen to the radio or read a magazine these days without seeing advertisements for supplements. The following information covers some of the most popular remedies and treatments:
Coenzyme Q10 (Ubiquinone) — Besides being part of the “energy chain” in your cells, CoQ10 is believed to function as an anti-oxidant in lipoprotein tissue (lipoprotein is the last “L” in LDL and HDL cholesterol) and to help stabilize cell membranes. It may work alone or as a back-up for vitamin E. Low blood levels of CoQ10 have been found in persons with heart disease. Studies have found that supplementation with CoQ10 has improved heart function in patients.
Cranberry Extract (Characterizing Ingredient: Quinnic Acid) — May inhibit the ability of certain bacteria to adhere to the lining of the urinary tract. May be helpful for maintaining health of the urinary tract.
Echinacea— Extracts from the leaves, flowers and roots of this purple coneflower are among the most widely used botanical products in North American and Europe. A limited number of test-tube evidence suggests that this herbal supplement stimulates immune processes (by stimulating phagocytosis, the process in which cells destroy invading bacteria and viruses) and increases mobility of white blood cells important in maintaining our bodies’ defense mechanisms. Last August, in a review in the Journal of Family Practice, researchers concluded that taking Echinacea at the first sign of a cold might reduce the illness’ duration. The majority of studies done on Echinacea, however, have not found it to be effective in preventing colds. Persons with auto-immune diseases (such as Type I diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis or multiple sclerosis, and those with suppressed immune systems, i.e., AIDS, HIV infection or tuberculosis), should not take echinacea without consulting their physician.
Evening Primrose Oil— May have anti-inflammatory properties. It contains Gamma-Linolenic Acid (GLA) - Prostaglandin E1 (a metabolite involved in the inflammatory response, is made from GLA). This agent may aid in reducing atopic (skin) and other types of inflammation; studies have shown both positive and negative results. Some women find it useful taken in the days prior to menstruation (to reduce cramps and discomfort).
Feverfew— One of its ingredients has anti-inflammatory , anti-spasmodic effects on smooth muscle tissues (such as blood vessels). That component may suppress the production of substances that have inflammatory effects (like prostaglandins). Feverfew may encourage healthy blood vessel tone. It is widely used in England for persons suffering from migraine headaches.
Garlic— Considered a medicinal plant for well over 5,000 years, garlic contains a component called “allicin,” which has been shown to inhibit the production of cholesterol by the liver. Allicin has antibacterial properties and also forms a compound called ajoene, which is believed to prevent platelet aggregation, thereby reducing blood clotting. Population studies have found an association between lower cholesterol levels and increased intake of garlic, onions and related vegetables. However, over the last five years only two well-designed clinical trials have found a cholesterol-lowering benefit of garlic supplements. At this time, no hard evidence exists proving that taking garlic will decrease your blood-cholesterol . Adverse effects of garlic supplements include: mild abdominal discomfort, and body/breath odor (odorless garlic is available). By the way, there have been cases reported of unwanted interactions between garlic and Coumadin (the blood-thinning drug, warfarin.)
Ginkgo Biloba— Acts as a vasodilator and free radical scavenger (a compound that reacts with and eliminates reactive chemicals that damage/degrade cells), the characterizing ingredients in ginkgo are associated with improved blood flow and increased oxygen metabolism, especially in the arteries and capillaries in the brain. It is widely recommended in Europe for poor circulation, short-term memory loss, headache, tinnitus (ringing in the ears) and related disorders. A 1997 clinical trial found that patients with dementia caused by Alzheimer’s disease or mini-strokes , who took 120 milligrams of ginkgo biloba extract per day scored somewhat higher on tests of mental performance than those who took a placebo. In the majority of cases, those who took ginkgo appeared to have delayed mental decline— about 20 percent of patients may have actually had a slight improvement. But those effects were modest. At this time there is no solid proof that ginkgo biloba will cure or prevent Alzheimer’s disease or that it will meaningfully improve mental performance. While ginkgo biloba appears to be generally safe for healthy people, it has been shown to interact adversely with blood-thinning medications such as aspirin and warfarin (Coumadin.)
Ginseng— An Oriental root, also known as “red” or “hot” ginseng, it is thought to have stimulative properties. Ginseng is used for many reasons, but the most commonly agreed upon use is as a general tonic. Ginseng is called an “adaptogen;” it is believed to improve the body’s ability to adapt to stress. In China, it has been used for centuries to improve concentration, boost resistance, combat weakness, and increase libido. Glucosamine and Chondroitin— These natural body substances contribute to joint strength and are usually taken together in supplements for treating osteoarthritis. An analysis of 15 studies published in the March 15 issue of JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association) found a moderate effect on pain relief and improved mobility with glucosamine, and a large positive effect for Chondroitin. (The researchers warned, however, that some of the studies may be biased or flawed and expect actual efficacy to be more modest than the studies imply.) Comparison studies have shown them to be at least as effective as the pain-reliever , anti-inflammatory ibuprofen (Motrin, Advil). Some evidence shows that supplements may actually slow the progression of cartilage loss in affected joints. These supplements need to be taken for more than one full month for their full therapeutic effect. The short-term safety profile appears good, and analysis of possible long-term adverse effects is currently under way. There are concerns about drug interactions for people taking blood-thinning medications as well for those patients with insulin resistance (a significant cause of type 2 diabetes).
Grape Seed Extract— Largely contains proanthocyanidin, which has been shown to have antioxidant effects. Grape seed extract may reduce oxidation of lipoproteins (oxidation of lipoproteins is believed to be one of the first steps in the formation of cholesterol plaque (hardening of the arteries).
Kava— An extract from the root of the pepper plant Piper methysticum, kava has come a long way from the South Pacific, where it has been a staple of traditional medicine for centuries. Today in the U.S., kava is an herbal best-seller , often taken for its relaxing, anti-anxiety properties.
Melatonin— This brain hormone helps to regulate sleep patterns. Although there is evidence that melatonin supplements can affect the sleep-wake cycle, there has been little clinical evidence suggesting they can reduce insomnia. The belief that one’s nighttime melatonin levels decline as they age has been challenged by a recent study that found no significant difference in levels among older and younger subjects. A recent well-controlled trial found the supplement ineffective in reducing symptoms of jet lag, despite popular belief that it helps cut down post-travel “blahs” and weariness. Warning: For those with sleep apnea, using melatonin could make your condition worse. Several European countries now regulate melatonin as a prescription drug.
Papaya— This fruit contains protein and fat-degrading enzymes, traditionally believed to aid in the digestion of rich foods. It can be eaten raw, dried or cooked, and is available in pleasant-tasting chewable tablets.
Saw Palmetto— This botanical agent is made from dried, ripe berries of the saw palmetto palm tree, a native of the Southeastern U.S. It is used for symptoms of non-cancer related prostate gland enlargement (such as slow urine flow, common in older men). A 1998 review of 18 clinical trials published in JAMA determined that 75 percent of the men who used saw palmetto for two months reported an improvement in their symptoms. A recent trial found saw palmetto as effective as finasteride (the drug, “Proscar”) to relieve symptoms. Comparisons between saw palmetto and other medications that reduce prostate enlargement are currently lacking.
Spirulina— A micro-algae vegetarian source of Vitamin B-12 , iron, beta-carotene and the rare essential fatty acid, GLA. spirulina is thought to strengthen the immune system.
St. John’s Wort (Hypericum perforatum) — This perennial herb grows in many regions of the world, including North America. It has been used for centuries to treat mental disorders as well as nerve pain. In ancient times doctors and herbalists wrote about its effectiveness as a sedative and anti-malarial agent as well as a balm for wounds, insect bites and burns. Today, it is used for treating mild to moderate depression, anxiety, seasonal affective disorder and sleep disorders. St. John’s Wort is most widely used in Germany, where, in 1994 alone, doctors prescribed nearly 66 million daily doses for their patients with psychological complaints. (The herb is prescribed in Germany 20 times more than Prozac, the most widely used anti-depressant in this nation). No studies in long-term use have been conducted thus far. More research is needed to explore long-term effects and optimum safe dosage. St. John’s Wort is available as a capsule, tincture or tea. Research already conducted at the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine at the National Institute of Health (NIH) ) has found a similar rate of response with St. John’s Wort and standard anti-depressants . Clinical trials are well under-way at research facilities. Although short-term studies have already found that the herb is effective in treating mild and moderate depression, the research community and the public has been worried by the recent finding that the herb might block the therapeutic effect of numerous medications, including birth control pills. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a public-health advisory specifying that health-care providers should alert patients taking St. John’s Wort and other drugs about the possible decrease in efficacy).
Acupuncture—One of the oldest, most commonly used medical procedures in the world. Originating in China more than 2,000 years ago, acupuncture became widely known in the United States in 1971 when New York Times reporter James Reston wrote about how doctors in Beijing, China, used needles to ease his abdominal pain after surgery. Research has shown that acupuncture is beneficial in treating a variety of health conditions.
Traditional Chinese medicine theorizes that the more than 2,000 acupuncture points on the human body connect with 12 main and eight secondary pathways called meridians. Practitioners of Chinese medicine believe that these meridians conduct energy or “qi,” between the surface of the body and its internal organs. Qi is thought to regulate spiritual, emotional mental and physical balance, and is influenced by opposing forces known as yin and yang.
According to Chinese beliefs, when yin and yang are balanced, they work together with the natural flow of qi to help the body achieve and maintain health. Acupuncture is believed to balance yin and yang, keep the normal flow of energy unblocked, and restore health to the body and mind.Traditional Chinese medicine practices (including acupuncture, herbs, diet, massage, and meditative physical exercises) are all intended to improve the flow of qi. The NIH reports that Western scientists have found meridians difficult to identify for they do not directly corr espond to nerve or blood circulation pathways. Researchers believe the meridians are located throughout the body’s connective tissue, while others do not believe that qi exists at all. These differences in opinion have made acupuncture a source of scientific controversy. Although some well-controlled scientific studies have shown acupuncture to be effective, more research is needed to better understand how and why the process works. Clinical studies at the NIH have demonstrated that acupuncture is an effective treatment for nausea caused by surgical anesthesia and chemotherapy as well as for dental pain experienced after dental surgery. Medical researchers have also found that acupuncture is useful by itself or combined with conventional therapies to treat; addiction, headaches, menstrual cramps, tennis elbow, muscular strains, osteoarthritis, lower back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, asthma and even as an aid in stroke rehabilitation.
Looking to the Future
At this time, the scientific foundation behind alternative medicine is inadequate. While there is a wealth of data documenting the growth in popularity of alternative care and some very promising early data on the effectiveness of certain modalities, it has not been clearly determined which treatments work, which do not and which can cause harm to the patients who use them.
Nurse Asbrand feels that we are headed towards a partnership of integrative medicine in our future, “the best of both worlds,” as she calls it..“As Baby Boomers are now feeling that sense of mortality,” she added, “many are looking towards therapies alternative to conventional medicine,” she said.
Contact Tammy Asbrand, R.N. at at 253-8929 .
