One thing has been lost in all the furor over the city’s secret backing of Councilwoman Jill Klajic’s private lawsuit against the Castaic Lake Water Agency:
Once the disclosure was made that the council secretly voted Sept. 7 to authorize City Attorney Carl Newton to assist Klajic’s lawsuit, the order was never rescinded.
That is, officially, the city attorney is still authorized to help Klajic in her efforts to overturn the CLWA’s purchase of the Santa Clarita Water Co. — a water retailer that some city leaders had coveted.
The council should immediately rescind that order, and should vote— publicly— to direct the city attorney to refrain from any involvement in Klajic’s personal legal battle.
There is a litany of things wrong with the way the city has handled this situation, from moral and legal standpoints.
The Sept. 7 closed session was an illegal meeting. Newton says it was not— and he is a very intelligent attorney. But other very intelligent attorneys disagree with his generous interpretation of the Brown Act, the state’s open-meeting law.
Regardless, what happened was clearly wrong: The council, once deciding not to sue the CLWA in order to block the water agency’s purchase, continued discussing in closed session the issue of whether the city should assist Klajic’s private lawsuit.
That’s the moment at which the discussion should have gone public, but did not.
The Brown Act allows municipalities to conduct closed-session meetings to discuss certain matters, like personnel issues and litigation in which the municipality is involved. It was clearly not intended to allow City Council members to secretly vote to use public resources for their own private legal battles.
In the Sept. 7 meeting, the council voted 3-2 to allow Newton to consult with Klajic’s attorney and to provide a legal analysis for Klajic’s case that had been purchased by the city.
The three votes in favor of the action were cast by Mayor Jo Anne Darcy, Councilwoman Jan Heidt and Klajic herself— who voted in favor of an action that could directly benefit her. Klajic stood to gain far superior legal counseling than she would otherwise get, and she and her co-plaintiffs — Lynne Plambeck, Joan Dunn and Jackie Bettencourt— would gain a legal analysis that was supposedly prepared in anticipation of possible city legal action, and only became officially “public” when the council decided to hand over the valuable legal research to Klajic and friends.
The rationale for the decision was that the private lawsuit, if it succeeded, would further the city’s interests.
That makes no sense when you consider that the City Council had voted not to participate in the lawsuit. How does secretly “assisting” in Klajic’s lawsuit further the city’s interests?
Can you say Trojan horse?
None of this was disclosed to the public until The Signal broke the story more than three months later, too late under state law for the city to be penalized for any illegal closed-session activity that may have taken place.
Under state law, such illegal meetings must be reported within 90 days— a flaw in our state’s open-meeting statutes that ought to be rectified at the next available opportunity. If municipalities like Santa Clarita succeed in keeping illegal decisions secret for an extended period of time, the clock ought to start at the moment of disclosure, not the moment of the illegal action itself.
All of this caused much hue and cry, and much finger-pointing at City Hall— much of it toward this newspaper. Through all of that, the city and Newton have yet to point out even one factual error in this newspaper’s coverage of the story, despite openly accusing the newspaper of being “inaccurate” and even “lying.”
Still, the situation remains: While Newton may not actually be continuing to assist Councilwoman Klajic’s private litigation— at no expense to her— he is still officially authorized to do so.
That authorization never should have occurred in the first place, and it never should have been hidden. Now, it’s time for the council to officially withdraw that authorization.
In public.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
