You just can’t win in this town.
At least, you couldn’t blame some people at City Hall for feeling that way, given the debate over the plan to restripe McBean Parkway to six lanes between Valencia Boulevard and Interstate 5, a process that would include the removal of 25 trees.
It’s the sort of project one might imagine would gain all sorts of approval from local residents: It increases traffic capacity on a major local thoroughfare, which is important because of the increased demand that will be created by temporary closures for interchange improvements along Interstate 5 during the next few years. The plan also calls for several new traffic signals, which should help increase pedestrian and motorist safety.
All this, and the developer is paying the million-dollar bill for it. Given the fact that traffic is supposedly one of the top local concerns, you’d think the community would be solidly behind the plan.
Just one hitch: Many in the community are up in arms about those trees.
City officials say 25 eucalyptus trees need to be removed as part of the restriping, in part because some of the trees don’t meet federal standards for distance from the road. It’s not only a legal issue but also a safety issue.
It has been ironic to watch as local environmentalists— including leaders of SCOPE, the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment— protest the possible destruction of trees that were planted along McBean as The Newhall Land and Farming Co. developed Valencia.
In other words, the activists were trying to preserve the neighborhood as it was developed by Newhall Land— typically SCOPE’s biggest target.
The dispute has also prompted a flurry of uninformed opposition, including some posts on this newspaper’s online Tell It to The Signal forum in which people have complained that the city will be cutting down “all” of the trees along McBean in order to “widen” the road.
There are a couple of key pieces of misinformation in such statements:
1: There are some 200 trees along that stretch of McBean. The vast majority will remain. Approximately one-eighth of them will be removed, and none of the median trees will be removed.
2: McBean Parkway is not being widened. The road is already wide enough to accommodate six lanes of traffic, but is striped for four lanes.
The project, simply, would remove the trees that are too close to the road and restripe it for six lanes. For every tree removed, two more will be planted— and 87.5 percent of the trees along McBean Parkway will remain. But word has spread around town like a game of “telephone.” The rumor mill has generated images of a tree-devouring city clearcutting its way through Valencia, denuding the town in the process.
That’s not the case at all, but the city faces the public relations nightmare of dealing with misinformed opposition.
Obviously, the city must do its best to inform all residents of the reasons behind the restriping— and its importance in light of the traffic demands that will be created by the I-5 construction.
We’ll do our best to help the city get that word out, but here’s a suggestion to help all residents better visualize what the impact will really be: The city should consider some way of marking the trees that would be removed— perhaps a red flag or something like that— so one could traverse McBean Parkway and visualize the impact before it occurs.
It stands to reason that, if only one in eight trees is marked, most observers would conclude that the overall visual impact would not be nearly so severe as the swath of destruction being portrayed by some of the more paranoid opponents of the restriping of McBean Parkway.
Can the city win this one from a public relations standpoint? On the whole, yes— because there’s a much less vocal majority out there that will appreciate the McBean Parkway improvements. But the fact will remain that, no matter the benefit, there is a vocal minority that will still object if even one eucalyptus is turned into firewood.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
