To hear Michael Kotch and his supporters talk, it’s OK to break promises if you’re an environmentalist.
That’s exactly what Kotch did a little over a year ago, when he decided not to run for re-election to the Newhall County Water District board of directors, yet refused to relinquish his appointed seat as the NCWD’s representative to the Castaic Lake Water Agency’s board.
His refusal came despite the fact that he had criticized his predecessor for doing exactly the same thing, and despite the fact that he had pledged— in writing— to resign his CLWA seat if he were not re-elected to the NCWD board in November 1999.
At long last, Kotch’s Year of the Broken Promise has come to an end.
Kotch’s original four-year term on the CLWA board expired Monday, more than a year after Kotch refused to allow the NCWD board to appoint a representative of its choosing.
Here’s what happened:
In 1995, Kotch was elected to the NCWD board, which later voted to appoint him as the water retailer’s representative on the board of the CLWA, the wholesaler of State Water Project water in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Under a deplorable set of special rules enacted by 1980s legislation, the valley’s water retailers— including the public NCWD and the developer-owned Valencia Water Co. — have appointed seats on the CLWA board.
Clearly, the spirit of that legislation was to have the retailers’ representatives serve at the pleasure of the retailers. It’s difficult to imagine, for example, that a Valencia Water Co. appointee would ever refuse to move aside if the company terminated his or her employment.
Yet that’s what Don Hayes— Kotch’s predecessor as the NCWD’s appointee— tried to do. He initially refused to move aside, and was roundly criticized by Kotch and this newspaper. At that time, we supported Kotch’s assertion that Hayes should move aside so Kotch could begin serving, which was the wish of the NCWD board.
Hayes relented, and Kotch assumed his rightful place as a CLWA board member, having been chosen by his fellow NCWD board members as their delegate to the wholesaler’s board.
In the aftermath of the Hayes incident, much discussion was made about the rules of play, and most observers agreed that, even if the representatives officially are appointed to “ four-year terms,” in the spirit of ethics and fair play, those representatives should serve at the pleasure of the agency that appoints them.
That only seems logical, and Kotch agreed, writing, “I agree voluntarily that, should I not be re-elected to the NCWD in November 1999, I shall resign my CLWA seat as a courtesy.”
Yet, that pledge was tossed aside when a new board majority took office in 1999—Êa majority whose politics run counter to Kotch’s anti-growth environmentalism.
The new majority tried to appoint Barbara Dore as its CLWA representative. But Kotch, ignoring both his own word and his own criticism of Hayes three years previously, refused to move aside— and has continued to occupy a seat on the CLWA board despite the fact that he is no longer an NCWD board member and the NCWD board no longer desires his representation.
His success in flouting the wishes of the NCWD board points out yet another flaw in the SCV’s retailer-wholesaler water relations. Clearly, those appointed positions should not exist in the first place— but since they do, those appointees should only serve at the pleasure of the retailers who appoint them.
In essence, as a result of Kotch’s refusal to honor his word, the current NCWD board has not had a representative on the CLWA board for the past year.
Kotch’s supporters point out that he has maintained a minority environmentalist voting presence on the CLWA board, thus ensuring that opposing views are at least aired.
While there certainly is something to be said for the presence of a minority voice on a political body, it should not come as a result of hypocrisy and broken promises.
