The City Council took a step in the right direction Tuesday when Councilman Cameron Smyth directed staff to work out a plan to exempt “historic” signs from the city sign ordinance.
‘Even if you consider it “only” a 50-year-old sign, you have to admit that if there’s a “historic” sign in the Santa Clarita Valley, it’s the one that lures passers-by off the road and into the Saugus Cafe.
While Smyth didn’t say it, it was evident he was referring primarily to the sign atop the Saugus Cafe, which the city sign police ordered to come down by Dec. 31.
The sign hasn’t come down— nor should it.
Established inside the Saugus Train Station in 1887, the Saugus Cafe is the oldest continually-operating restaurant in Los Angeles County. It moved across Bouquet Canyon Road more than 100 years ago and was remodeled in the 1950s, when a new sign was placed above its roof.
Even if you consider it “only” a 50-year-old sign, you have to admit that if there’s a “historic” sign in the Santa Clarita Valley, it’s the one that lures high-speed passers-by off the road and into the Saugus Cafe.
Planning Director Jeff Lambert said Wednesday that the city will let the cafe owners make their case to save their sign. We hope the city makes the right decision. Though there are problems with the sign ordinance in general, the cafe owners have shown good faith by removing their smaller signs to comply with it.
Councilman Smyth’s interest in saving “historic” signs opens another door.
Last year then-Councilwoman Laurene Weste, now mayor, raised the notion of a historic preservation ordinance. It’s something the city should move up on its agenda.
Not only could a historic preservation ordinance save worthy signs, but also entire buildings. Santa Clarita is full of history but there’s nothing on the books today to preserve it.
The city tried to implement a historic preservation ordinance about a decade ago but the effort was thwarted when preservationists and property owners couldn’t agree on what should be saved.
Rather than ignore the issue altogether, the city should learn from those past mistakes and craft an ordinance that balances property rights with the wishes of those in the community who want to keep our most precious historic assets from being lost forever.
Certainly every old building can’t and shouldn’t be saved just because it’s old. But the city could start with the historic buildings identified in the General Plan, then figure out which have true historic importance and work with property owners to develop a set of rules that will entice them to save the best of the past— perhaps with some money or other forms of consideration like an exemption from the sign ordinance.
The ordinance shouldn’t be limited to buildings, either. There is no law, for instance, to save Beale’s Cut— the crevasse in the Newhall Pass that enabled our pioneers to traverse the mountains almost 150 years ago. Beale’s Cut may be a state historic landmark, but state historic landmark status has no teeth. It doesn’t protect the cut from a developer’s bulldozer. Only local government can do that.
Saving the historic Saugus Cafe sign should be a no-brainer . Once that’s done, let’s do the hard work of saving other historic properties around town.
