If a place or a building has state or national “historic landmark” status, then it’s protected, right? Wrong.
There’s a pervasive misconception that state or federal recognition somehow saves a historic site from demolition. In fact, state or federal status is just that— a status symbol, to be enjoyed and shown off by the owners of the historic site.
‘Mayor Frank Ferry is right: Just because something is old, doesn’t mean it’s historic. But by the same token, as it stands, just because something is historic, doesn’t mean it will be saved.’
Protection— saving a historic site from a bulldozer— is something which, for all practical purposes, can happen only at the local level.
This week the City Council took an important first step toward protecting some of the buildings and places that have played important roles in the development of our community. The council devised a framework to guide city staff in crafting a historic preservation ordinance, intended to help spare what’s left of our history.
History is something in which Santa Clarita is particularly rich. The first gold in California was discovered right here in Placerita Canyon, six years before James Marshall pulled his famous nugget from Sutter’s Mill. California’s oil industry was born in a little town— now a ghost town— just west of Interstate 5. Western film got its start when Santa Clarita’s rugged canyons became Hollywood’s backlot.
Los Angeles joined the rest of the nation when the rails from north and south came together in Canyon Country. The state’s second worst disaster happened in Saugus when William Mulholland’s St. Francis Dam broke, spilling a wall of water that killed 450 people by the time the flood reached the Pacific.
It’s an important history that’s worth remembering and celebrating. Remnants from each of these monumental events— and more— still dot the landscape, from the Oak of the Golden Dream where a Mexican cattleman uprooted the first gold nugget, to the homes of oil driller Charles Alexander Mentry in both Placerita Canyon and Mentryville.
There is little argument that a structure such as Beale’s Cut should be saved— the man-made gash in the Newhall Pass that enabled wagons and the first cars to traverse the mountains.
Beale’s Cut is an example of something with State Historic Landmark status— but no law on the books to keep it from being bulldozed. Beale’s Cut is owned by a developer who plans to build a commercial complex next to it; fortunately the city had the foresight to order the developer to save it, as a condition of approval.
But many more historic homes and buildings have already fallen because there are too many holes in the system. Without a coordinated plan to save historic structures, in some cases the case-by-case methods have failed.
Not too many weeks ago we reported that a prehistoric site with many Indian artifacts in the Leona Valley was bulldozed— only because nobody checked its background. The consolation is that it wasn’t in Santa Clarita— but without a competent system in place, it easily could have happened here. It’s been a few years, but the examples inside city limits are woefully numerous.
Mayor Frank Ferry is right: Just because something is old, doesn’t mean it’s historic. But by the same token, as it stands, just because something is historic, doesn’t mean it will be saved.
Now the city is on the right path. A survey of historic properties will determine what’s out there, and hopefully the city will establish an oversight committee to hammer out the details of what should be saved.
If it’s craftily done, perhaps modeled after Old Pasadena’s, with some sort of monetary incentives for affected property owners who are willing to maintain the historic character of their properties, a historic preservation ordinance that saves what’s gone before could be the ticket to a future that sets Santa Clarita apart from the cookie-cutter Southland.
