What will the city’s trash audit determine?
Frankly, it’s not yet known— and anyone who professes to know is either filling your head with lies, speaking too soon or engaging in wishful thinking.
‘The auditing firm— Ernst & Young— is still gathering information. No “clean bill” has been given, nor has the auditing firm reported any damning conclusions.’
The City Council unanimously ordered an audit of the city’s trash franchises last year after numerous questions arose about local trash collections costs and discrepancies in the city’s waste diversion and recycling rates, which reflect whether the city is in compliance with state trash reduction law.
Some facts were known going into the audit, and some were unknown. Hopefully, the audit will help flush out some of the important information that will better equip the City Council to decide whether to sign a new contract with the three existing haulers— Atlas, Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal— or put the contract out for competitive bidding.
Among the known facts: The current residential trash collecting rates in Santa Clarita are high in comparison to other cities in the region. We pay more for trash collection than most cities in Southern California. Further, it is known that the city’s reported waste diversion numbers are abysmal, falling well below the 50-percent waste reduction required by state law.
What’s also known: City trash rates in 1996 were set based on incorrect “tipping fees,” the amount a hauler pays to a landfill in order to dump trash. Instead of the fees actually paid by haulers, residential trash rates were set based on the so-called “gate rate” — the posted fee at the landfill for drive-up customers. Trash haulers typically negotiate contracts that call for tipping fees well below the gate rate, and the local haulers are no exception. If the actual tipping fees had been used, it’s highly probable that Santa Claritans’ trash service would be cheaper.
What has caused these very real problems? Is it simply a poorly negotiated contract? Has there been actual wrongdoing by anyone— haulers, city staff or both? Did we get to this point by simple human error or something else?
Those questions are legitimate, given the facts that are known. And we’d be extremely surprised if the problems can be entirely chalked up to something like “careless paperwork.” But the answers are not yet known.
The audit was designed to get to the bottom of these and other questions, and to provide the city with a detailed accounting of the trash franchises, ranging from the setting of rates to the amount of revenue generated to the questions about recycling.
Contrary to the conclusion one might draw by reading a newspaper headline that, for example, says, “City trash audit gives clean bill,” the audit is not yet complete.
The auditing firm— Ernst & Young— is still gathering information. No “clean bill” has been given, nor has the auditing firm reported any damning conclusions. The target date for completion is the end of the month, but it is not yet clear whether extra time will be needed.
In the meantime, we are reserving judgment on the audit. Everyone else should, too.
