Much has been made recently of this newspaper’s position on growth— and our call for some new, enforceable way of managing it.
And during that debate, there have been those who contend that, since the paper did not support a 1992 growth-control ballot measure, it did not support managed growth.
That’s not true— and there’s an important distinction to draw as the community evaluates the potential tools that can be used to prevent new residential growth from further overburdening our roads, schools and other infrastructure.
That distinction is as follows: Simply because one does not approve of a numeric cap does not mean one isn’t in favor of well-managed , well-controlled growth.
The failed 1992 ballot measure was opposed by many in this community— and, of course, by the development industry— because it called for an annual numeric cap on the number of new homes that could be built in the city of Santa Clarita.
Surely, different entities had different motives for either favoring or opposing the measure. But the fact remains it was the wrong approach to control the area’s growth, for several reasons.
‘A numeric cap isn’t the answer, but what’s important is to build a consensus on what sorts of approaches might work to better control and manage growth not only in the city of Santa Clarita, but also in the county territory that surrounds it.’
Among those reasons is the fact that a numeric cap within city limits would do nothing to manage growth where it needs to be managed most: Outside Santa Clarita city limits, in the unincorporated territory that falls under Los Angeles County’s jurisdiction.
Most of the valley’s undeveloped territory was carefully carved out of the proposed city of Santa Clarita by the county boundary-setting agency— the Local Agency Formation Commission— before the city incorporated in 1987. Thus, most of the growth since then, and most of the growth that will occur in the next decade, is targeted for land outside city limits.
Further, a numeric cap ignores the free market principles that are supposedly valued in this country. Obviously, a land owner’s rights to build must be balanced against the rights of existing residents not to be unduly impacted by new growth— but in general, market forces, not an arbitrary cap, ought to direct the ebb and flow of development. Odds are, even without a numeric cap, the numbers will average out over time.
All that said, this doesn’t mean the various sides of the growth issue can’t have a meeting of the minds. A numeric cap isn’t the answer, but what’s important is to build a consensus on what sorts of approaches might work to better control and manage growth not only in the city of Santa Clarita, but also in the county territory that surrounds it.
Hopefully, in the months ahead, those various factions will make a sincere effort to focus not on their differences, but on their potential for common ground.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
