“For sale: Good genes, athletic donor with high SAT scores. Tall, blonde, blue eyes. Highest bid over $150,000.”
That sort of advertisement would be the logical follow-up to this week’s news that a couple has advertised their willingness to pay $100,000 for the eggs of an intelligent, young, white athlete, someone under age 30 with a proven record of college-level athletic ability.
The ad, which appeared this week in Stanford University’s school newspaper, has disturbed medical ethicists who are wondering aloud whether upping the ante for egg donations would be a healthy trend.
One would normally hope that altruism— a sincere desire to help couples who can’t conceive children on their own— would be a primary factor for someone considering egg donation.
But when you put a big-bucks payoff into the mix, you increase the chances that unscrupulous donors will come forward— perhaps individuals who doctor up their records or conveniently forget to disclose potentially important information about their medical or family history.
‘One would normally hope that altruism— a sincere desire to help couples who can’t conceive children on their own— would be a primary factor for someone considering egg donation.’
Technological advancements have been a great help to many couples who want to have children, but need assistance. Some individuals have been able to use that technology to their advantage, while others have chosen a more selfless route, adopting children who have already been born and need the love and safety of a good home.
Each method has its up sides.
The question is, at what point are we misusing the technology— and is it right to throw a six-figure payoff on the table while ordering your child’s characteristics off a menu?
Regardless of one’s conclusions, it is a topic that warrants careful thought— and careful steps by the industry.
The ad in the Stanford paper reads: “Give the gift of love and life... Very special donor needed.”
What that fails to recognize is that, in this case, it’s not a gift at all. It’s a high-dollar business transaction. And there’s something unnerving about that.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
