It’s the sort of compromise that should have been reached long ago.
The Castaic Lake Water Agency and one of its board members— Ed Dunn— have finally agreed on an arrangement that keeps Dunn out of closed-session discussions of a lawsuit in which his wife is suing the CLWA, but still allows him to participate in closed-session meetings on other issues.
It’s an agreement that is fair to both sides.
‘As a board member, Dunn is clearly entitled to participate in the closed-session discussions of other personnel and pending litigation items. But there’s something clearly wrong with him participating in closed-session discussions of his wife’s lawsuit against the agency.
This compromise allows for both.’
The issue of whether Dunn should participate in closed sessions arose when his wife, Joan, became a plaintiff in a lawsuit seeking to overturn the CLWA’s purchase of the Santa Clarita Water Co.
Joan Dunn, along with Councilwoman Jill Klajic, Newhall County Water District board member Lynne Plambeck and activist Jackie Bettencourt, contends that the CLWA’s purchase of the water company is illegal because the CLWA— the local state water wholesaler— is not entitled to act as a water retailer. CLWA officials— and a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge— disagree. Joan Dunn and company have appealed that ruling, so the case is still pending.
State open-meeting law entitles public agencies to meet in closed session to discuss pending litigation. That exception to the Ralph M. Brown Act is intended to give public agencies the opportunity to discuss legal strategies confidentially— a valuable tool that serves the best interests of public agencies involved in legal conflicts.
For obvious reasons, public agencies typically don’t invite their legal opponents into such closed sessions.
Hence, the CLWA contended that Dunn should not participate in closed-session discussions of his wife’s lawsuit. From a technical standpoint, it constituted a potential conflict of interest: If Dunn’s wife were to win the lawsuit, it could benefit the Dunns financially because Joan could recover legal fees.
But even if that didn’t constitute a legal conflict of interest, it constitutes a moral one.
The conflict had evolved to the point where the CLWA was considering suing Dunn to force him out of the closed-session talks.
However, this week the two sides reached a logical, sensible compromise that should have been reached months ago.
The board and Dunn agreed that discussions of his wife’s lawsuit will be scheduled last on closed-session agendas, and Dunn will be allowed to participate in the closed sessions up to that point.
Seems simple, yes?
It really is. As a board member, Dunn is clearly entitled to participate in the closed-session discussions of other personnel and pending litigation items. But there’s something clearly wrong with him participating in closed-session discussions of his wife’s lawsuit against the agency.
This compromise allows for both. Dunn can participate in other closed-session discussions, then excuse himself from the meeting when the board takes up the subject of his wife’s lawsuit.
It’s a reasonable solution, and local taxpayers are fortunate that Dunn and the CLWA didn’t have to resort to another court battle to reach it.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
