The emotions are understandable. When one thinks one’s quality of life or property values are at stake, one is likely to react vehemently, even angrily.
But this is another in a long line of cases where the City Council must weigh what is best for the overall community, not just the wishes of the vocal few.
The issue in question is whether McBean Parkway— between Del Monte Drive and Interstate 5— should be restriped from four to six lanes.
The opposition to the project focuses on two general areas of concern: Added traffic and the planned removal of 25 eucalyptus trees.
The trees need to be removed, city officials say, because they are too close to the roadway. Opponents say the tree removal would destroy the visual appeal of the McBean corridor, while others say the 25 trees constitute a small percentage of the approximately 200 trees that line the road.
These issues came to the fore once again Thursday night at a city-hosted community meeting in which City Manager George Caravalho presented the project— and alternatives— to interested local residents.
Caravalho must have felt like he had a bullseye on his chest. He was barraged with questions and angry comments by residents who live along the McBean corridor and contend the proposal will render their neighborhood not only less attractive, but also less safe.
‘It seems everyone in town wants road improvements until those road improvements are proposed to come too close to their homes.’
City officials say the restriping is necessary for several reasons, including the fact that traffic on McBean has already increased as the northern portions of Valencia are developed and as the Valencia Marketplace shopping center— on the other side of I-5 — has drawn traffic from within the city.
The restriping is also considered necessary because Caltrans plans a long series of I-5 freeway improvements that are expected to temporarily increase the burden on surface streets like McBean.
As a condition of development approvals, The Newhall Land and Farming Co. agreed to cover the $1 million cost of the McBean project, which also includes two new traffic signals on McBean.
As always seems to be the case, there are those who oppose the project. It seems everyone in town wants road improvements until those road improvements are proposed to come too close to their homes.
It’s difficult to blame those people for their concerns. They’re only trying to protect their neighborhoods, their homes, their property values.
However, a few factors are worth considering, even if you live along McBean.
Among them: The traffic is coming, restriping or no restriping. How well do you think those property values will perform if the traffic is crammed into four lanes, moving at a snail’s pace? The lower the capacity of the road, the easier it will be for it to become gridlocked.
Further, McBean Parkway will remain one of the most attractive thoroughfares in the city. In fact, Caravalho told the residents Thursday night the city had come up with an alternative that removes only seven trees instead of 25.
That didn’t do the trick, though. For some residents, the only acceptable solution is no restriping at all— and not one tree touched.
The decision will ultimately rest with the City Council, and as the council members contemplate the next move in the McBean Parkway trees and restriping saga, their judgment should be determined by one overriding factor:
What’s best for the entire community?
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
