That was an interesting little incentive Browning-Ferris Industries threw into the mix as the city revisits its contract for the local trash hauling franchise.
The offer essentially amounts to, “Hire us, and we’ll not only cut your constituents’ trash rates by 20 percent, but we’ll also vanquish one of your worst enemies.”
That “enemy,” in this case, is the possibility of a trash dump in Elsmere Canyon— a mega-landfill plan that galvanized the Santa Clarita Valley in opposition during the 1990s much like the Transit Mixed concrete mining plan has done in 2000 and 2001.
This is a story that could take years to completely unfold, due to the nature of the city’s contracts with local waste haulers. City officials say that, under the automatically renewing terms of those “evergreen” deals, Atlas Disposal, Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal would have the equivalent of five years’ notice that the city may switch haulers.
That delay is just as well, because it is not a decision to be made lightly, and its impacts are far-reaching . The City Council is scheduled Tuesday to take up the issue, as it is faced with the decision of allowing the annual automatic 12-month contract extension or informing the three haulers that the city intends to open up the franchises to a bid process.
BFI has made it clear that it intends to be a major player in such a process: BFI wants the contract, and is willing to throw a pretty big bone to Santa Clarita in the form of Elsmere Canyon. And in all of the excitement over Elsmere, let’s not forget that 20 percent rate cut. If it’s for real, at the very least it puts our local haulers on the hot seat as they negotiate with the city— and that issue, not Elsmere, is the one that most Santa Claritans will really notice.
The city should approach its talks with all four haulers with two adages in mind: 1) If it sounds too good to be true, it may very well be. And, 2) Never take the first offer without negotiating.
On its face, BFI’s offer is enticing: A 20-percent cost cut plus Elsmere Canyon. Elsmere, long the site of a proposed 190-million-ton trash dump, is coveted by many activists as a potential park or nature preserve. The landfill plan, originally put forth by BKK Corp. in the late-1980s , at the time would have been the world’s largest trash dump. Local residents turned out in droves to oppose the dump, citing a litany of concerns including its impact on the environment, traffic and underground water supplies.
But the dump hasn’t materialized, thanks largely to the hard work of numerous local activists and legislation introduced by the SCV’s Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon. The legislation, signed into law in 1996, bans a federal land swap that would have been needed to remove Elsmere Canyon from the Angeles National Forest, thus clearing the way for the dump.
BFI, which operates the nearby Sunshine Canyon Landfill, has since taken over ownership of the land in Elsmere that was targeted for the dump— and now, as part of a proposal to take over the city’s trash hauling service, BFI is offering to give that land to the city.
Talk about a final nail in the coffin for the Elsmere landfill. Legislation can be overturned, but property ownership equates to real control. There would be no dump in Elsmere.
It’s an attractive incentive indeed.
But there are other points to consider. For example, if BFI’s first offer is to reduce trash rates by 20 percent, what might it actually be willing to do? And, if BFI is able to operate profitably in the SCV for 20 percent less— or even better than that— what kind of better deal might the city be able to strike with the existing haulers? Is BFI operating at a major advantage because of its ownership of the Sunshine landfill, and if so, is that monetary advantage too significant for the local haulers to overcome?
The existing haulers are a consideration, too. While Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal are both owned by trash giant Waste Management Services, they have each existed as locally operated businesses, with local employees, for many years, and Blue Barrel in particular has been an outstanding local citizen and active participant in community service-oriented events and projects. Those things should not be taken lightly.
But unfortunately for those haulers, BFI has put together an intriguing combination of reduced rates and a prized piece of property. If the BFI deal is everything they say it is, the city will be hard-pressed not to take it.
