Perhaps if the City Council refuses to do its job, Mother Nature will take care of it instead. We saw some evidence of such a possibility on Tuesday, when three large eucalyptus trees along McBean Parkway came crashing down, one of which smashed a parked pickup truck.
No one was killed. This time.
The incident was the latest illustration of what can happen when our City Council makes the wrong decision in order to appease a vocal minority. It’s a pattern we have seen time and again: The interminable delays in construction of the Wiley Canyon bridge; the city’s inability to get a major road— any major road— built in its first decade of existence; the city’s failure to make the entire stretch of Placerita Canyon Road available to the public; the blocking off of public roads, like Via Dona Christa and, now, most likely, the Valley Street-Calgrove Boulevard connection.
In these and other instances, including McBean Parkway, the council has made decisions that are in the best interests of vocal minorities— not the entire city. For some reason, no incarnation of our City Council has ever seemed to come around to the notion that they represent all of us, not just the people who object to a specific project.
We elect public officials to make difficult decisions, and sometimes that means standing up to an angry crowd in an emotion-packed meeting. Too often, our City Council has bended to the wishes of the angry crowd du jour.
Now, the council needs to revisit its ill-advised decision in September to forgo not only the restriping of McBean Parkway to accommodate increased traffic, but also the tree removal that would have accompanied the restriping.
We said it in September, and it bears repeating: This is about more than just smoother traffic flow, which is a worthwhile goal in and of itself.
This is also about public safety.
Certainly, trees can become uprooted during storms, and the McBean eucalyptus trees were not the only ones toppled by this week’s wind and rain. However, these were three of the trees that are perilously close to McBean— so close that some actually encroach upon the roadway. If you were predicting which trees were especially prone to the whims of a storm, this trio would have been near the top of the list.
The eucalyptus trees are not deep-rooted , and any casual observer can patrol McBean Parkway and find several trees that have collided over time with the curbs and gutters. One tree, in the process of toppling Tuesday, actually tore up the curb and gutter. Luckily, it fell away from the road, and the truck it struck was unoccupied. It would be comical if it weren’t so potentially serious.
Will we be so lucky next time, and if we’re not, will we be able to escape the conclusion that tragedy could have been averted if the City Council had only done the right thing— for everyone?
When the restriping of McBean Parkway was proposed, it made sense, and still does. The road was designed to accommodate six lanes, so it would not have to be widened. It was initially believed dozens of trees lining McBean— one of the more scenic roads in town— would have to be removed for the restriping. But when residents objected, the city whittled the list, until finally the restriping would have only caused the removal of fewer than a dozen, those trees most likely to encroach upon the road, or fall directly onto it.
Ultimately, the council caved in to a group of residents who objected. Given the council’s long-existing pattern, we could have scripted that. Council members Laurene Weste and Frank Ferry voted in favor of the restriping, recognizing that upcoming construction along the Interstate 5 corridor will increase demand for alternate routes. But Bob Kellar, Cameron Smyth and Jo Anne Darcy did what so many past versions of the council have done: They yielded to whomever made the most noise on the night of the vote, and thereby yielded to the “not in my back yard” sentiments that have so often paralyzed our city at the expense of actions that would have been in the best interests of all residents rather than a vocal minority.
The McBean restriping and tree removal was stopped dead in its tracks, and ironically, Darcy told residents the traffic is coming, and they would “be coming back to us very quickly.” Essentially, she admitted that, by siding with them, she made the wrong decision.
The council can’t afford to have this decision go any more wrong. McBean Parkway will need the extra capacity and should be restriped, but just as importantly, some of those trees— beautiful as they may be— are simply too close to the roadway, and even encroach upon it. They constitute a very real potential hazard and should be removed.
The City Council should reopen its discussions on the McBean Parkway issue and take the appropriate action before Mother Nature intercedes once again— and use this as a catalyst for a new pattern of council behavior, one in which it makes the best decision for the entire city, rather than a vocal minority.
