ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Council’s trash decision must weigh all factors

Yes, a trash war is percolating in Santa Clarita. The first salvos have been fired, and whatever the outcome, this skirmish could pay off for taxpayers in the form of more competitive prices for trash collection and recycling service.

That could be with the existing haulers, or it could be with a new one.

Much has been made so far of the offer by Browning-Ferris Industries to donate a portion of Elsmere Canyon to the city in exchange for a long-term contract, which would oust Blue Barrel Disposal, Santa Clarita Disposal (both owned by Waste Management) and Atlas Consolidated Services, owned by Republic Industries, Wayne Huizenga’s company. All three companies, then, are parts of huge national conglomerates.

Elsmere is far from the key point of any deal for a new trash hauling contract. The real keys are price and service.

And given the fact that BFI, which operates Sunshine Canyon Landfill, has offered to cut trash rates by 20 percent, it behooves the city to listen to what BFI has to say. If residents pay 20 percent less for their trash collection, it would amount to a savings of more than $50 per year, per household— in other words, more than $2.5 million citywide.

That’s why the City Council did the right thing Tuesday night. In a split vote, with Councilman Frank Ferry dissenting and Councilwoman Jo Anne Darcy abstaining— but voicing objection— the council ordered city staff to get more details from BFI on its proposal to take over the city trash franchise.

It was the sort of measured, careful step called for by the situation. Atlas, Santa Clarita Disposal and Blue Barrel have long-standing , positive relationships with this community, and those relationships should not be ended or jeopardized lightly. But the council is obligated to get the best deal it can for taxpayers, so it would be irresponsible to walk away from the BFI offer without finding out more about it.

The council’s other possible choices were to vote in favor of the annual one-year extension of the city’s contracts with the three existing haulers, or to inform those haulers that the franchise agreements would be put out to bid, giving the haulers five years’ notice the existing contracts would be terminated.

Mayor Laurene Weste and council members Cameron Smyth and Bob Kellar did the right thing: They didn’t make a rash decision to go to bid right away, but they didn’t merely extend the haulers’ contracts without finding out more about BFI’s offer.

The best thing may prove to be putting the contracts up for bid. Getting the best deal for taxpayers means securing the best combination of price and quality service. While we are getting quality service by all accounts, there are many who believe Santa Clarita residents and businesses pay too much for trash collection. A competitive bid process— with a fixed-term contract that has no “evergreen” clause to automatically perpetuate it, such as the one that exists now— could be the best way to ensure that Santa Claritans get the right service at the right price.

Before we do that, it’s worth asking, “How credible is that offer from BFI?” As Smyth pointed out Tuesday night, the proposal submitted in writing to the city is short on details, and prompts a variety of follow-up questions.

For example: BFI offers a 20-percent rate cut. Twenty percent of what? Our existing rates, or the rates at the end of the existing haulers’ five-year grace period? How long would those rates stand?

How will BFI’s service compare to what we have, and what guarantees can they provide for quality service? What role would BFI play in the community? Local Waste Management Manager Karl McCarthy has done a fine job of giving back to this community in the form of monetary and in-kind contributions and by providing many free services to the city and community groups. Would BFI step up to the plate similarly?

What about BFI’s request for a 20-year deal? Is that a take-it-or-leave-it proposition, or would they be willing to negotiate on it? Considering the fact that most cities sign five- to seven-year deals, two decades seems out of the question.

What about the Elsmere portion of the deal? What does BFI mean when it promises to give a “significant portion” of the property to the city? Which acreage, and under what conditions?

Does the city “owe” anything to Waste Management, or is it the other way around? How much money has the company made from Santa Clarita over the years? Have Waste Management or BFI committed to open their financial books to assure that the public is being charged fairly? A complete, independent annual audit must be part of the agreement between the city and any hauler. That’s one of the prices a hauler should pay for the privilege of an exclusive deal with the taxpayers of our city.

The answers to these questions and others are relevant as the council decides whether to open up the bid process. The answer may be that the existing haulers are best equipped to serve this community. But it would be irresponsible for our elected leaders to turn a blind eye to an offer like that being made by BFI.

However, if all things were equal, especially the price to consumers and businesses, the city should give Waste Management the nod. As Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal, it has been in this community for decades and has been a good corporate citizen. If the proposals are similar, Waste Management deserves the preference. It was strongly supported by important, influential community members at Tuesday’s meeting. They have earned that support through community service and a history of good, dependable service.

On the other hand, if BFI would really save residents and businesses 20 percent on trash hauling, it cannot be ignored by responsible elected public officials.

Further, we do not understand Councilman Ferry’s angry, inappropriate outburst at Tuesday’s council meeting. Is there something we don’t know? Was there a back-room deal that went sour? Ferry chastised Mayor Weste for having the nerve to meet with BFI instead of sending them to City Manager George Caravalho. Councilman Ferry, when did it become a crime for the mayor to meet with a potential major city contractor? Weste merely heard from BFI about what their offer would be, and left the decision-making to be done in open session. So long as no open-meeting laws were violated— and they weren’t— that’s the sort of thing we’d expect our mayor and Councilman Smyth to do, as the two of them comprise the council’s committee on waste issues.

George Caravalho is a good guy, but we didn’t elect the council just to do what he tells them to do. We would prefer that they do their own homework and think for themselves.

For example, city Planning Director Jeff Lambert said Tuesday night an 11th-hour agreement with city staff, Waste Management and Atlas (Republic) complied with “everything” the city wanted. Weste then pulled out a list of what the council had asked for from the haulers in April 2000. There were numerous items that were not addressed in the negotiations between city staff and Waste Management, the most glaring of which was a rate reduction. Waste Management most assuredly did not give the city “everything” it wanted. Perhaps they offered a good deal, perhaps not. The near future should tell. But the current haulers clearly did not provide everything requested, as was misrepresented by the staff at Tuesday’s meeting. Giving Lambert the benefit of the doubt, perhaps it wasn’t intentionally misrepresented. It could be an issue of semantics, but it was misrepresentation nonetheless.

This is why the whole negotiation should be done in the wide open spaces of the democratic process. Not in a City Hall private meeting room. Not over cocktails in a hotel room on a junket. Staff recommendations should be considered strongly and weighed against what may or may not coincide with the public interest, depending on the issue at hand. But City Council meetings should not be rubber-stamp sessions, as they often seem to be.

Smyth, Weste and Kellar have indicated they wish to make an informed decision on the future of waste hauling in the city of Santa Clarita— just as they should.

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/signal/0201/021801a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,385 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/12 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council, Elsmere]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”, “Smyth”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0