As the city of Santa Clarita and the Castaic Lake Water Agency debate over which of them should buy the Santa Clarita Water Co., one can't help but worry over possible drawbacks of either scenario.
And, as the two entities began haggling this week in a joint committee meeting to hammer out their differences, Santa Clarita Councilman Frank Ferry made an off-the-cuff suggestion: Why don't they pursue a joint purchase?
It didn't exactly draw a warm reception, nor would you expect it to. The various parties — officials and staffers of the city and CLWA — each have an interest in gaining control of the company, the valley's largest water retailer.
But the best thing they could each do for the taxpayers of this valley is to work together. At least on the surface, it appears a joint city-CLWA purchase could be the ideal solution to this brewing problem.
There's no doubt that whoever controls the water company wields significant power and the ability to dramatically influence the way this community will grow, or not. It also represents a tremendous amount of revenue for a local public agency to manage, a reality that must be watched carefully to prevent government abuse.
These factors can't be ignored as sources of motivation for both the city and the CLWA. And when it comes to taxpayers' best interests, there is a down side to such a consolidation of power on the part of either the city or the CLWA.
For example, a city takeover of the water company — current city claims notwithstanding — poses the risk that residents' water costs will increase. Consider the experiences of our neighbors to the south, where the Metropolitan Water District has become a mechanism for the redistribution of capital: Customers who own homes in certain areas pay more for every gallon of water they use than those who live in apartments or condominiums, a pricing structure that constitutes a discriminatory hidden tax on owners of homes.
Santa Clarita cannot deny that it has engaged in similar behavior. For example, the city's trash collection franchises include a hidden tax: The franchise fees we all pay for guaranteed monopolies for three trash haulers are really hidden taxes that are largely responsible for the fact that Santa Claritans' trash hauling costs are higher than those in many comparable Southland cities.
Since the city has many other issues on its plate, it will be possible for issues like water rates to be lost in the political shuffle. One can easily imagine a scenario in which a council member goes along with a rate hike because it will be overshadowed by other issues and would not threaten the politician's re-election.
From this perspective, there's an up side to a CLWA purchase: The water agency is only in the water business, and as a result is likely to feel more accountable solely on water issues.
But there are potential negative side effects to a CLWA solo purchase of the water company, too. For example, it would come with some risk that undue influence could be exerted by development interests. With all due respect to The Newhall Land and Farming Co. — which generally does a fine job of planning community growth — the developer already has one appointee on the CLWA board through its ownership of Valencia Water Co. A CLWA purchase of Santa Clarita Water, which has its own CLWA appointee, could create the impression that power is further consolidated on behalf of development interests, diminishing voters' influence.
Also, there's concern over whether a state water wholesaler that's accountable to the entire valley should get into the business of serving as the retailer for a portion of the community. Would that best serve all valley residents, or just those who buy water from that retailer?
In a perfect world, a private party would materialize to buy the company. This would offer the least risk to taxpayers. However, failing that, it seems compromise and teamwork are in order.
Here's a suggestion:
The city and the CLWA should immediately put aside any personality differences and work together in the best interests of taxpayers. They should pursue the formation of a joint powers authority to purchase the water company. That JPA should be overseen by a board of directors including two of the publicly elected — not retailer-appointed — members of the CLWA board, two members of the City Council and one "at large" member elected by the public.
Right from the start, the public could realize a cost benefit: If the city and CLWA negotiate together, rather than competing, they'll drive the price of the water company down to a fair level.
For now, it's merely a suggestion — but it's one that would facilitate the apparently inevitable sale while putting the city and CLWA on equal footing, letting each monitor the other and, hopefully, ensuring a reasonably priced, high-quality local water supply.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
