Pride and savvy can be conflicting qualities, and such is the case with the talks over which entity will purchase the Santa Clarita Water Co.
The city of Santa Clarita and the Castaic Lake Water Agency each have the possible purchase in their crosshairs, and given the fact that the city and the CLWA have at times had a rocky relationship, there is an air of competition about the proceedings.
But if ever there were an important time for those two public entities to cooperate rather than compete, this is it.
It's not an overstatement to say the very course of the valley's future growth and economic development could be determined by the sale of the Santa Clarita Water Co. The sale of the company to a public agency would produce a dramatic shift in the local balance of power.
The City Council is scheduled tonight to take up the issue once again, and we'd like to encourage both parties to work together instead of against each other.
Santa Clarita Water is the valley's largest water retailer, and it's for sale. It's in the best interest of the owners — the Bonelli family — for the city and the CLWA to compete for the purchase, since that scenario will inevitably drive the price higher.
But if the city and CLWA agree to work toward a joint purchase, the taxpayers' interests will, in all likelihood, be better served. A joint powers agreement between the city and CLWA would not only help keep the initial purchase price down, but it would also help establish a system of checks and balances to ensure that, in the future, the water company is run in the best interests of its customers and of the Santa Clarita Valley population as a whole — a delicate balance.
Therein lies the conflict:
Pride, on the part of the city and CLWA, leads each to pursue a solo purchase with the notion that it is the better agency for the job.
But savvy, if applied to this situation, would reduce taxpayer costs — and the Bonelli family's profits — by driving the price down.
One scenario that we've put forth is for the JPA to be governed by a five-member board including two of the publicly elected members of the CLWA board, two members of the City Council and one at-large member elected by the public — perhaps with voting and candidacy restricted to residents who live within the water company's service area.
This would provide joint oversight that would, hopefully, serve all interests well, and keep one-time costs (the purchase price) and ongoing costs (residents' water rates) within the bounds of reason.
But none of that will happen unless the city and CLWA start — now — by taking that first important step:
Cooperating.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
