If you're a golfer in the Santa Clarita Valley, odds are you're still stinging from the sale of the Valencia Country Club: The valley's premiere course, which for years had been accessible to the public, went private after Uniden bought it from The Newhall Land and Farming Co. about 10 years ago.
So it's understandable to an extent if, when you hear Newhall Land is planning a spectacular new course as part of its 1,711-home Westridge development, you cynically come to the conclusion that you'll be able to play the course for just a few years before it gets sold to some entity that will make it a private club with astronomical membership fees.
Further, when you hear Newhall Land's pledge that the course will remain accessible to the public as a "daily fee" course for a minimum of 10 years, you can't help thinking: Ten years, then it goes private.
Those are understandable thoughts for golfers who feel as if they have been "burned" once already — but if you talk to Newhall Land officials privately, it does seem as if they're sincere in their desire to keep the course public.
The course itself is a potential boon for the community: It will be a Tournament Players Club course, virtually assuring that it would become host to an annual PGA Tour event. Given the positive effect the Nissan Open had last year when it was played at the Valencia Country Club, it seems clear that an annual PGA stop in the Santa Clarita Valley would be an economic and tourism plus, to say the least.
The developer's intention, clearly, is not to merely leave the Westridge course open to the public for only the 10 years that have been promised to the Los Angeles County government, then turn it into a private country club. The intention, it seems, is to keep the course publicly accessible in perpetuity.
But there are a lot of "ifs" in the world of business and sport.
For example: What if golf wanes in popularity?
What if there is a plethora of new, publicly accessible courses in the SCV in 10 or 15 years?
What if the course starts losing money?
What if Newhall Land goes out of business?
While these scenarios seem unlikely, any smart company would leave itself an "out" — just in case — even if it fully intends to do business a certain way, i.e., keeping a golf course open to the public.
Yet it's understandable for the local golfing community to be skeptical.
With that, we offer a suggestion: Perhaps the developer can make a pledge to the community, independent of its formal commitment to the county, to keep the course open to the public so long as certain conditions exist.
It's not the sort of thing that ought to be imposed on Newhall Land by the government — as a matter of principle, once the government has authorized the formation of a new business, it ought to meddle in the actual operation of the business as little as possible.
However, Newhall Land could go to greater lengths to assure the public that, assuming certain conditions continue to exist, the golf course will continue to be available for public play.
For example, it could make a pledge that includes stipulations about factors like the number of golfers who continue to use the course over time, the course's profitability, competition from other courses and Newhall Land's continued existence as a local business.
Crafted properly, such a pledge could not only provide residents greater assurance of Newhall Land's intentions with respect to the Westridge golf course, but also give the developer the escape hatches it truly would need in the event that circumstances change. What it would amount to is a promise to the community that, "We intend to operate the Westridge golf course as a daily fee course in perpetuity so long as the following conditions exist ..."
If such a pact were made, perhaps some of the community's skepticism about the future accessibility of the Westridge course would diminish.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
