Don’t be overcome by emotion— in either direction.
That’s about the best advice we can offer the City Council, which tackles a difficult issue Monday night when it holds a special meeting to discuss whether to extend the city’s contracts with three local waste haulers or put Santa Clarita’s residential and business trash collection franchise out to bid.
‘As much as we like to be loyal to good service providers like Waste Management, and as much as the name, “Elsmere Canyon” has meant in a decade’s worth of local political battles, council members should not be distracted by those issues.’
There are emotional factors that could come into play in either outcome.
One one hand, local leaders have a great deal of personal loyalty to the local haulers— Atlas, Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita disposal companies. Waste Management, which owns Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal, is an outstanding corporate citizen, contributing cash and services to many good local causes.
And on the other hand, it’s all too easy to be enticed by the prospects of bringing Elsmere Canyon into public ownership— a possibility put forth by Browning-Ferris Industries, which owns property in Elsmere that was once targeted for development as a trash dump. BFI, which operates the nearby Sunshine Canyon Landfill, has offered to give the bulk of its Elsmere property to the city in exchange for a long-term trash contract.
What’s called for, though, is neither blind loyalty to existing haulers nor starry-eyed notions of finally slaying the Elsmere Canyon dragon. This decision should be neither personal nor emotional.
The fact is, many residents and businesses in Santa Clarita believe they could—Êand should— be getting the same trash hauling and recycling services at a lower price. This belief seems to be reinforced when one compares Santa Clarita’s trash rates with those of other cities, and it seems to be reinforced when one takes into account the fact that BFI claims it could cut local trash rates by 20 percent if it were given the city trash contract. This is enticing, but what about commercial rates? Will BFI lower trash rates to local businesses? It is not yet clear.
And, the fact is, Elsmere Canyon is no longer the threat it once was. Yes, the donation of coveted potential parkland is, on the surface, an attractive enticement, but it should not be considered in the context of “saving” Elsmere from becoming a landfill; 1996 legislation by Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon essentially slayed that dragon. There’s little or no reason to believe it needs slaying again.
The biggest real issues facing the council Monday night are cost and quality of service— and the council’s decision on whether to extend the contracts or go to bid should be based mostly on those factors.
Is BFI’s offer too good to be true? Would it provide service that is comparable to the service Santa Claritans are already receiving, and is the price cut for real? How would the BFI proposal change if it were not granted the completely unrealistic 20-year agreement it seeks?
Can the existing haulers make important concessions to the city, like cutting rates, eliminating the “evergreen” portion of the franchise agreements and including an independent annual audit in the haulers?
All of these issues are the real crux of the challenge facing the council Monday night.
As much as we like to be loyal to good service providers like Waste Management, and as much as the name, “Elsmere Canyon” has meant in a decade’s worth of local political battles, council members should not be distracted by those issues. Rather, council members should carefully weigh their decision based on what is the best way to get the best deal— the best combination of price and quality of service— for local taxpayers.
The council is obligated to do nothing less.
