There were those who thought local politics in Santa Clarita might get boring after last year’s City Council election, in which Bob Kellar and Cameron Smyth were added to the council.
The election of Kellar and Smyth meant that, for the first time, Santa Clarita had a council that appeared unified: Five Republicans, with largely similar views on the big-picture issues facing our community.
Harmony was predicted. Anti-growth activists envisioned that highways and strip malls would replace every oak tree in town. Local political wags expected a long series of 5-0 votes and pleasantries to flow from the council dais.
And in the past couple of weeks, as the all-Republican City Council has argued, debated, cajoled, questioned, pondered and fumed, first over the Valley-Calgrove gate and then over the fate of the city’s trash hauling contracts, there are those who have been wringing their hands:
What happened to the harmony?
What happened to the unity?
What happened to the pleasantries?
Well, largely those things still exist. We still have a City Council whose members largely agree on the big-picture issues facing our community. They all have common-sense approaches to the most important issue facing us: Growth. They all believe in preserving the integrity and socio-economic health of our uniquely sophisticated but safe community. They all believe in well-planned , controlled, responsible growth.
But we also have a City Council that does not necessarily agree 100 percent of the time.
It is working, just like a local government should.
When tough issues come before a local governing body, it’s their job to ask questions, argue (in a professional manner), debate, hem and haw, and voice their own uncertainty.
That’s exactly what has been happening with our City Council on the question of whether Santa Clarita should keep its three existing trash haulers— Santa Clarita Disposal, Blue Barrel and Atlas Disposal— or put the local trash franchise up for an open bid process.
That question is more sharply pointed than in past years, because Browning-Ferris Industries, operator of the Sunshine Canyon Landfill, has offered to cut local trash rates by 20 percent and give the city a significant portion of Elsmere Canyon— once the proposed site of a major trash dump— in exchange for a long-term exclusive contract.
The debate has occurred publicly, our council members have not always agreed, they have changed their minds, they have voiced their disagreements (sometimes loudly), and they have, quite honestly and openly, stated that they haven’t felt ready to make a decision until more facts are known.
That’s exactly what happened at the end of the council’s debate on Monday night: After four hours of citizen testimony and council discussion, the council voted 3-1 , with Councilman Frank Ferry abstaining and Councilman Cameron Smyth casting the dissenting vote, to delay its decision one week.
To the casual observer it may seem like confusion and disarray. And in some ways, it is. But the City Council is trying to sort through the confusion and disarray, make sense of it all and make the right decision. It’s not a decision to be taken lightly— every Santa Clarita taxpayer’s trash service and a potential $350 million contract hang in the balance— and to its credit the council is not taking the decision lightly. Clearly, the majority of the council is leaning toward awarding a renegotiated contract to the current haulers, but Mayor Laurene Weste and city attorneys presented some issues with the proposed contract that Weste and council members Bob Kellar and Jo Anne Darcy decided warranted further study.
When all was said and done Monday night, the prudent thing to do was to sleep on it, and that’s exactly what the council did.
More homework is being done by this City Council than some past councils, and that’s how decisions should be made. We would much rather see council members researching issues and asking questions instead of simply casting a vote to return political favors, responding to political threats, or taking the closed-government , non-democratic approach and just doing whatever the city staff recommends.
Monday’s meeting was not one of our more harmonious moments as a city. But the dynamic we’re witnessing— the debate, the dissent, the uncomfortable squirming on the horns of a dilemma— illustrates that, even if one does not agree with the ultimate outcome, the process is working. Your city government is doing at least some of its most important business out in the open for all to see.
Politically “unified” council or not, that’s a victory for us all.
