None of the options are at all attractive— and this predicament has been a long time in the making, with plenty of blame to be spread around.
The William S. Hart Union High School District governing board is scheduled tonight to choose the least of several evils in an attempt to devise a junior high and high school schedule that will help the district cope with the worst overcrowding in its history.
The unattractive options included staggered, college-style schedules; split schedules, with classes divided into early and late sessions that may overlap; double sessions, with early and late schedules that do not overlap; and, multi-track , year-round education, with “tracks” similar to those that are common in Santa Clarita Valley elementary schools.
Each of the options has its own unique lack of appeal.
Staggered schedules would create gaps— perhaps lengthy ones— in the school day. Where will the kids go during the gaps, how will they get there and what will they do?
Split schedules and double sessions would pigeon-hole students into either “morning” or “afternoon” school, and essentially create two campus communities in one. Those in the afternoon sessions might be less inclined— or less able— to participate in extracurricular activities, and older high school students on afternoon sessions may find it more difficult to hold down part-time , after-school jobs or to attend community college classes.
And don’t even get parents started on multi-track , which is almost universally unpopular. In practice, multi-track generally works fine at the elementary school level once families become accustomed to it, but at the high school level it creates a different set of problems. Can all programs be offered equally to all tracks? What about “ off-track ” students participating in extracurricular programs, like athletics? It would be disruptive, at the very least.
All of this leaves the Hart governing board in an unenviable position tonight, because it does not have the option of doing nothing. More student capacity must be created, and soon, without the “luxury” of actually building new schools.
Looking for areas to cast blame? You can start back as far as 1978.
That’s when California voters approved Proposition 13 to limit property taxes. While Prop. 13’s provisions— in which a home is only assessed at its full market value when it changes ownership— have helped keep many Californians more comfortable with their tax bills, its passage was the beginning of the end for California schools, once among the best in the nation.
Since Prop. 13’s passage, the state’s commitment to funding public school construction has sharply declined.
And more recently on the legislative front, we have seen the development of a three-pronged state school construction funding formula that has left districts like the Hart district strapped for construction cash.
The three-pronged program is one problem that was created to solve two others: The state’s failure to cover the costs of keeping older campuses up to date, and the development industry’s failure to ensure new residential development is accompanied by adequate school space.
As it stands, developers can’t be forced to cover the cost of new schools necessitated by residential growth. They are only accountable for a state-determined fee that constitutes one of the three “prongs.” The other two prongs are local school bonds and state matching funds, which, ironically, cannot be obtained without the passage of local school bonds.
The difficulty of achieving that has been compounded by the fact that an undemocratic two-thirds supermajority has been required for approval of local school bonds— although Proposition 39, approved by California voters in November, drops that supermajority to 55 percent. Under the old rules, Santa Clarita Valley voters last year narrowly failed to approve a bond measure that would have brought in more than $140 million in state matching funds. With the failure of Measure S, we missed out on that money.
It all adds up to a recipe for underfunded, overcrowded schools.
And that’s exactly what we have here in the Santa Clarita Valley, which is why the Hart District governing board is in the position of choosing whatever is determined to be the “least evil” of the aforementioned unattractive options for local school schedules.
It’s unenviable indeed— not just for the school board, but also for the students who will be paying the price.
