At least it’s over.
You might say that about many stressful events: Selling a home. Changing jobs. Taking the SAT.
‘It probably wasn’t the best deal the city could have gotten. But it was a better deal than the city had a month ago.’
Choosing a trash hauler.
And even if you’re not satisfied with the outcome of Tuesday night’s City Council meeting, it appears we can express exactly that sort of relief about one of the more stressful chapters in Santa Clarita’s political history.
At least it’s over.
Well, part of it anyway. Many difficult questions remain about Santa Clarita’s trash and recycling statistics— questions that will need to be answered over the next few months. And, the City Council, before granting its final approval of the new trash contracts, should still revisit the notion of reducing the city’s trash tax, euphemistically described by the city staff as a “franchise fee,” which costs each resident $2.21 per month and generates approximately $1.35 million per year for city bureaucrats to spend as they see fit.
But the decision on who will haul city residents’ trash for the next decade has been made, with a 4-1 council tally in which Mayor Laurene Weste cast the lone dissenting vote.
The council decided to stick with Atlas Consolidated and two local firms owned by trash giant Waste Management: Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal companies. Each will retain its share of the local franchise, with Atlas covering 15 percent of the city and Waste Management serving 85 percent. Residents will pay the same amount they have been paying for trash and recycling service— $22.13 per month— but senior citizen rates will be cut to $15.
In the end, it probably wasn’t the best deal the city could have gotten. But it was a better deal than the city had a month ago, when Browning-Ferris Industries attempted to muscle its way into the local trash hauling scene with an attractive-sounding proposal to cut local trash rates and donate a portion of Elsmere Canyon to the city.
BFI’s proposal had flaws— the company wanted a 20-year deal, which is ridiculously long— but the proposal was the catalyst for tougher talks between the city and the existing haulers.
Much of the credit for the improved deal should go to the mayor.
Weste has been criticized by some who became weary or impatient with her detailed analysis and relentless questioning of such important topics, but our mayor’s stubbornness, if you will, directly resulted in a more effective trash contract. Weste does her homework, and it paid off.
This was an important debate over what ended up being a 10-year contract, and it deserved the time and attention that was given to it.
Whether you agree or disagree with the council’s decision, it appears the system for the most part worked. Yes, there are aggravating failures, like the failure of four Republican City Council members to support Councilman Cameron Smyth’s suggestion that the city cut its trash tax.
But on the whole, the council’s wrangling over the issue generated results, even if the city didn’t get everything it could have out of the negotiations. The council debated the issue, changes were made and city residents ended up with an improved trash deal.
It wasn’t fun— especially for the people directly involved— but in the long run it was productive.
Local taxpayers still didn’t get the cut in the city trash tax— which they should get— and they still didn’t get the rate reduction many had sought.
However, some important concessions were made: The “evergreen” clause was eliminated, meaning the contract is now a 10-year fixed deal. Under the former evergreen provision, the contract was essentially self-perpetuating , with an automatic renewal built in each year. Also, the new deal calls for the city to conduct annual audits of the haulers— a power that the city has previously had but never invoked.
And, the new pact improves the senior citizen discount and freezes overall residential rates for four years.
Could the city have done better?
Most likely, yes. It was clear from the concessions made Tuesday by the haulers that the city could have— and probably should have— held out for a rate reduction. Still, the contract is better for taxpayers now than it was a month ago. There’s satisfaction to be drawn from that.
That, plus the fact that at least one big chapter of Santa Clarita’s great trash debate has come to an end.
