What good is it to appoint a committee to decide an issue, and then withhold all of the pertinent information from it?
The answer is obvious, but that’s just the predicament that seems to be facing the city’s task force on Transit Mixed.
‘It’s a little tough to serve on a committee that isn’t privy to the city’s proposals or its secret discussions with the mining company.’
The city of Santa Clarita appointed an advisory committee of community leaders and activists last month, following the Jan. 23 hearing at which the county Board of Supervisors ordered the city and Transit Mixed Concrete Co. to sit down and resolve their differences.
Ostensibly the idea for the citizens’ committee was to help the city wade through the negotiation process and act as a sounding board for the city’s counter-proposals to the company that wants to mine tens of millions of tons of sand and gravel in Soledad Canyon over the next 20 years.
At first the talks were cloaked in secrecy, but the wraps came off when Transit Mixed announced its offer to shave a few million tons of concrete from its plans. The city countered with a proposal 10 times smaller, akin to the mining that has been going on in Soledad Canyon for many years. Obviously the offers were made in such a way that each side knew the other wouldn’t accept them.
Next, the city created the “Transit Mixed Executive Advisory Committee” and appointed interested parties to it, such as Bob Nolet, superintendent of the Sulphur Springs Union School District, and longtime TMC fighters such as Pauline Harte.
It seemed this committee would wade through all of the documentation for the mining proposal and help city staff members come up with a plan that would protect the health, safety and welfare of the residents of the Santa Clarita Valley, within the framework of the “good faith” negotiations as ordered by the supervisors.
But when the committee met Wednesday, it discovered that the city already had developed a new counter-offer without it.
Thus the question: What’s the point in having a citizens’ advisory committee if city staff members are going about their business without it, crafting counter-proposals on their own?
As Nolet pointed out, it’s a little tough to serve on a committee that isn’t privy to the city’s proposals or its secret discussions with the mining company.
Councilman Bob Kellar suggested that the city give the committee executive-board status. Evidently that status would enable the committee to meet behind closed doors, where it could then be made aware of what’s going on without sharing it with the rest of the public until it’s deemed appropriate to do so.
That may not be the only answer, or even the right one.
When you cut to the chase, there are really only two possibilities for the negotiation process, before the issue goes back to the county supervisors. Either the city and Transit Mixed will negotiate in good faith and meet somewhere in the middle, or they’ll fail to reach a compromise and stay at odds, leaving it for the supervisors to hash out.
The best approach is simply to let the new committee do its work, put everything on the table and discuss all of the offers and counter-offers in public. After all, the resulting offer from the city should be something that has the broadest buy-in from the community— an offer that the residents can fully support.
Otherwise, the citizens’ oversight committee members will be relegated to the role of cheering section for whatever decisions the city makes without them.
