The SCOPE anti-growth club still wants to have it both ways.
‘SCOPE is blocking the valley’s largest developer from building a new school, while at the same time blaming that same developer for not building enough schools.’
That much, at least, was illustrated when Jill Klajic, former City Council member and a leading member of Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, attended Wednesday’s unit holder meeting of The Newhall Land and Farming Co.
Klajic—Êwho picketed along with SCOPE Vice President Lynne Plambeck outside the Hyatt Valencia before the meeting— openly acknowledged trying to sabotage the jobs of construction workers who honked as they passed her picket. Said Klajic: “Don’t they know we’re trying to take away their jobs?”
Inside the meeting, Klajic complained that Newhall Land does not build enough schools, and even incorrectly asserted that Valencia is becoming known as “the land without,” in terms of schools and water.
That’s ironic, and it illustrates the shallow hypocrisy of the SCOPE anti-growth movement.
Newhall Land just recently broke ground for a new elementary school to accompany its Bridgeport development, and SCOPE itself is trying to block the construction of Rio Norte Junior High School in Newhall Land’s West Creek development, at a time when the entire Santa Clarita Valley— not just the west side— needs new schools.
In other words, SCOPE is blocking the valley’s largest developer from building a new school, while at the same time blaming that same developer for not building enough schools.
It’s amazing how all of those words can come out of two sides of one mouth.
SCOPE, along with the Sierra Club and Ventura County, have requested a legal review in order to block The Newhall Land and Farming Co.’s 2, 500-unit West Creek development, based on the assertion that an adequate water supply does not exist for the new development and the accompanying Rio Norte Junior High School.
The opponents’ protest to the Public Utilities Commission will be reviewed by an administrative law judge, and in the meantime the school and the development are on hold.
And the school remains stalled despite the fact that Newhall Land had asked that the school be separated from the development for purposes of the review, which would clear the way for the school to proceed without guaranteeing that the final residential approvals would follow.
But SCOPE and its partners in protest refused, and continue to block the junior high school— which is needed now to relieve already overcrowded schools, and would use only about 25 acre-feet of water per year, an amount approximately equivalent to the amount used by 50 average households.
One can’t help wondering whether it’s simply SCOPE’s strategy to prevent new schools from being built wherever possible, which gives its anti-growth , anti-economic development members like Klajic the opportunity to contend that development should not proceed because of a shortage of schools. It’s a new twist on the notion of a self-fulfilling prophesy.
Given situations like the Rio Norte debate, the irony is overwhelming when Klajic or anyone else from SCOPE complains about SCV school capacity.
To his credit, Gary Cusumano, replacing the retiring Tom Lee as Newhall Land’s chief executive officer, didn’t stand for Klajic’s hypocritical allegation— he called her on it, saying: “You belong to an organization that causes delays in schools.”
Cusumano is absolutely right. And while you may or may not agree with everything Newhall Land does in its role as a developer, ask yourself:
Who’s trying to build new schools and who’s trying to block them?
