In one respect, it seems like such a waste. Just think how much good it would do if the city of Santa Clarita had an extra $1.15 million to spend wherever it pleased.
Maybe the city could hire a few extra deputies to make our already-safe streets even safer. Or maybe the money could make some park improvements and give the local Little League a new place to play. Or maybe a road could be extended— at least a block or two.
But no, the city has spent $1.15 million to make something not happen. Specifically, that’s the amount allocated so far to fight the Transit Mixed Concrete Co.’s proposal to mine 78 million tons of sand and gravel in eastern Canyon Country over the next 20 years.
It’s a shame that’s what it has taken, and frankly, nobody seems to be too happy about it.
“I’m incensed we have to spend our time and money this way,” said Rick Putnam, the deputy city manager whose primary job function these days is to try to convince the concrete company not to wipe out Santa Clarita’s air quality, road capacity and water supply with a mining plan that’s too big for the area to handle.
Most of the initial $1.15 million has been spent on legal fees and environmental reports, and now Putnam is going back to the trough for more, asking the City Council to appropriate another $650,000 for the fight.
Is it worth the price? What are we getting for our money?
The Signal has been opposed all along to this mega-mining project— unlike the metropolitan newspaper to the south— and we remain opposed. But the new $650,000, like the $1.15 million before it, is, after all, the people’s money, so it’s incumbent upon us to take a close look at the balance sheet and collectively reach a comfort level that we’re getting the best bang for our buck.
That’s why we’re asking readers this week in our informal “Reader Meter” poll: “After spending $1.15 million, should the city of Santa Clarita spend another $650,000 to fight the Transit Mixed concrete mining proposal?”
Mayor Laurene Weste said last week, “The council is totally committed to (fighting) TMC. It is willing to sacrifice to win this issue for the community. We will drop everything to fight Transit Mixed.”
OK, that seems clear. Or does it? The issue seemed fairly cut and dry during 2000: The city was waging war to “Stop Transit Mixed” and would take no prisoners in its campaign to defeat the mine.
But the message got garbled in January when the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors ordered the city and other interested parties to sit down at the bargaining table with Transit Mixed and work out a compromise that would do the least damage to area residents but still allow the mining project, in some form, to proceed.
By all rights it looked like the city lost— but city staffers came away from the hearing saying they’d gotten what they wanted: a foot in the door to negotiate with the mining company.
City Council members and, from what we could tell, most of the public, seemed less certain it was a victory. Victory, it was presumed, would have involved the supervisors telling Transit Mixed to pack up its crayons and take them back to Houston— or northern Mexico, where the outfit’s parent company is headquartered.
Thus we must again ask: What is it, exactly, that this additional $650,000 is expected to accomplish? We’re told the first $150,000 of it is needed to carry the city through the end of the fiscal year (it ends June 30), so that would include the next meeting with the supervisors. And what will the supervisors do then? That’s a big question mark, because the sought-after negotiations between the city and Transit Mixed broke down last week when, apparently, neither side would budge from its opinion of how much gravel should be mined.
And just how much is too much, now that we know the city is willing to accept some amount greater than zero? There hasn’t been a clear answer from the city, beyond an initial counter-proposal asking the company to reduce the level of mining by a factor of 10.
So will the $650,000 be spent on lawyers, when the matter inevitably winds up in court? And if so, then what, exactly, will we be fighting for? The eradication of Transit Mixed? A 7-million-ton project? A 30-million-ton project? A project of indeterminable size, so long as the air, water and roadways aren’t severely impacted?
These questions and more need to be answered in detail before the City Council allocates a lot more of our money for the TMC battle.
