The images of Elian Gonzales were starkly contrasting:
Elian, in tears, fear on his face, being taken at gunpoint from the home of Miami relatives who have been caring for him since he was plucked from the sea on Thanksgiving Day.
Then, later that same day, Elian was all smiles as the camera captured him not in the arms of a federal agent or a government order-defying relative, but in the arms of his father.
Both images are important— and anyone taking an interest in the story would be well-advised not to forget the importance of the latter image: Smiling father and son, reunited after months of controversy.
Regardless of whether one agrees with the tactics employed by federal agents who seized Elian in a 5 a.m. raid Saturday, the raid at last placed the 6-year-old boy where he belongs— with his father. Hopefully for Elian Gonzales, this latest chapter is the beginning of the end of his five-month ordeal.
It’s important to remember that little Elian is just like any other 6-year-old . He likes to run and play, he gets a kick out of cartoons and he is impressionable. There’s little way of knowing what he really wants, and there’s no way of knowing how his feelings about the situation have been affected by what the adults around him have been telling him for the past several months.
But it is certain that Elian has a father who loves him and wanted him back after the boy was found floating in the ocean on an inner tube, alone, after a Florida-bound boat carrying him, his mother and others fleeing Cuba capsized, drowning all but Elian.
Elian’s fate became a celebrated political cause, with passions flowing heavily on both sides of the argument: Those who believed Elian should be returned to his father and his native Cuba, and those who believed Elian should remain with relatives in the United States, free of Fidel Castro’s oppression. Both arguments are compelling.
Is the United States a better place to live than Cuba? Most would agree that it is so. But this is more complicated than that; we should value the rights of parents to raise their own children, provided the parents don’t have histories of criminal activity or abuse.
There would be no reason to deny Elian’s father the right to raise his son, other than the fact that he happens to live in Cuba. That’s not sufficient reason to separate them.
The use of force ordered by Attorney General Janet Reno may have seemed extreme to the casual observer. The images of a tearful Elian being pulled from the Little Havana home tug at one’s heart. After all, what 6-year-old wouldn’t be frightened to be hauled away by armed men who burst into the home where he has been kept safe for the better part of five months?
That all, of course, was avoidable. If Elian’s relatives had obeyed the government’s legal orders to turn the boy over so he could be reunited with his father, no force would have been used.
Even if you feel force was still unnecessary, and that not enough was done to bring about a negotiated end to the standoff, the raid Saturday morning was a means to the proper end:
Putting Elian and his father back together.
