Just when you thought it was safe to go into the groundwater...
‘Caution is of the utmost importance. We don’t need new toxic problems to emerge while the development is in midstream. Porta Bella must have a clean bill of health before even one home is built.’
The Porta Bella nightmare just seems to get worse and worse.
According to a March 19 state Department of Toxic Substances Control memo, perchlorate— a rocket fuel component— has been found in groundwater as low as 200 feet below the surface of the Porta Bella property.
Perchlorate is just one of the approximately 275 known contaminants on the Porta Bella site.
Clearly, there are still unknowns surrounding the questions about development on the property, and the possibilities for its cleanup, and it seems like the more we learn, the more scary the prospects and potential impacts become.
That’s why the City Council owes it to the public to maintain its previous position: That phased development will not be allowed on the Porta Bella site, and that the new housing and commercial development can only proceed when the cleanup is complete.
Caution is of the utmost importance. We don’t need new toxic problems to emerge while the development is in midstream. Porta Bella must have a clean bill of health before even one home is built.
The council tonight is scheduled to hold a study session in which the property owner is expected to ask the council to reverse the past council decision and allow for phased development of Porta Bella.
The development is planned for a 996-acre site that is contaminated with toxic chemicals as a result of the decades-long production and testing of explosives and weapons on the site.
The former Whittaker Corp. and Bermite Powder Co. site is now targeted for 2,911 homes, along with related commercial development and public facilities, in the geographic center of the city, southeast of Bouquet Junction.
The City Council approved the development six years ago, on the condition that the soil and groundwater contamination on the site be cleaned up to the satisfaction of the state Department of Toxic Substances Control before any development can proceed. The council’s reasoning was sound.
The new owner of the property, Santa Clarita LLC, is a subsidiary of Arizona-based Remediation Financial Inc., which wants to build the project in phases, with the proceeds from one phase financing the cleanup of the next. This, of course, would make the project easier for the property owner to manage— but at what risks to the public?
Another financial wrinkle that the city staff has put back on the table is the possible use of redevelopment. Judging by the city staff’s prior attempted misuse of redevelopment after the 1994 earthquake, we are watching that carefully. If the city even considers pushing the redevelopment button for Porta Bella, it had better make sure it is following the letter and spirit of state redevelopment law.
The City Council can expect to receive pressure tonight to allow phasing, or to move in a new direction that might use local tax dollars— through redevelopment— to help solve the Porta Bella problem.
The council should not succumb to the pressure, and any decision should only be made after careful measuring of the facts and the potential impacts.
