The following is a reprint of a Signal editorial that first appeared March 19, 1997.
The U.S. Supreme Court took the right step Tuesday on behalf of the First Amendment’s right to free speech and free press by, in effect, reiterating that opinion statements are not subject to defamation lawsuits.
‘An opinion, such as whether a public official is incompetent, stupid, unfair or unfit for the bench is, by definition, not a statement of fact, and therefore cannot be libelous.’
The court refused to revive a former Kentucky judge’s libel lawsuit against the Louisville Courier-Journal over editorials that criticized her work and endorsed her election opponent.
The court, without comment, turned down the argument by the ex-judge , Jacqueline K. Schroering, who claimed the newspaper falsely portrayed her as incompetent.
The important thing about this case is the court ratified lower court decisions that correctly drew a distinction between false statements of fact— which can be the basis of libel lawsuits— and opinion, which is constitutionally protected.
The case stemmed from Schroering’s 1993 re-election bid for her spot as district judge in Jefferson County, Ky.
During the campaign, the newspaper published an editorial saying she had an “uncertain grasp of the law and an erratic temperament.’’ The newspaper quoted unidentified lawyers as saying they often left her courtroom wondering whether she understood their arguments. In addition, the paper said most lawyers questioned in a poll rated her as unqualified for the bench.
Schroering sued the newspaper after her defeat, but a state judge dismissed the lawsuit and a Kentucky appeals court agreed. The state court said the newspaper’s notes of interviews with lawyers backed up its statements about those interviews. There was no evidence that the newspaper acted with malice, the state court ruled, adding that the statements could not be proven false.
That is the key aspect of this case. To establish libel, a plaintiff must prove the publishing of a false, defamatory statement of fact.
An opinion, such as whether a public official is incompetent, stupid, unfair or unfit for the bench is, by definition, not a statement of fact, and therefore cannot be libelous.
The court’s decision was needed in light of a 1993 Supreme Court decision which has been incorrectly construed by some plaintiffs as saying opinion is not protected against libel lawsuits.
The 1993 case involved a newspaper columnist who made allegedly false statements of fact in an opinion column. In its decision, the court said you can’t get away with making false factual statements simply by labeling it “opinion.”
In other words, a columnist could be sued for stating, “In my opinion, Joe Smith is a child molester,” since the statement is not really opinion but fact, since it implies knowledge of facts which would be defamatory if true.
On the other hand, a statement like, “Joe Smith is the worst mayor in the city’s history,” is and should be protected as opinion.
Certainly, many newspapers columns and editorials may be considered offensive and hurtful to their targets. But in order to preserve the free and robust debate that is necessary for our democracy to survive, courts must protect the right to make derogatory opinion statements— especially about public figures.
