When the City Council voted last month in favor of a new contract with the three local trash haulers, there were those who viewed the issue as “resolved.”
An understandably so: The council had spent a tumultuous month debating whether to continue with Atlas Disposal (owned by Wayne Huizenga’s Republic Industries) and Santa Clarita and Blue Barrel disposal companies (both owned by trash giant Waste Management).
‘Fortunately, the council recognized that it’s better to sit tight while the waste diversion issue is sorted out. Council members voted unanimously to wait, rather than approve the (agreement).’
At issue was the question of whether the council could get a better deal by going out to bid for the local trash franchises.
Browning-Ferris Industries had informed the city it could provide a residential rate cut and would donate its property in Elsmere Canyon to the city in exchange for a long-term contract. Some aspects of the BFI deal were either too good to believe or were unrealistic (for example, BFI, which owns the nearby Chiquita Canyon Landfill, wanted a 20-year agreement, which is far too long of a commitment for the city to make).
The council ended up deciding in favor of sticking with the three existing haulers, and some attractive new changes were made to the proposed contracts— although a rate cut was conspicuously absent.
But just as the council was arriving at that decision, it became publicly known that there had been a dramatic spike in the city’s reported tonnage of trash going to landfills— putting Santa Clarita in danger of being found in non-compliance with state waste reduction law.
The council wisely decided to hold off on finalizing the new deal with the three existing haulers until a city consultant could get to the bottom of the waste diversion reporting problem.
So, in essence, even though the council had essentially put the hauler selection debate to rest, the issue had by no means achieved its final resolution. It would have been imprudent to rush into the new franchise contracts without first finding out what had caused the 68,000 spike in trash figures for 1999.
That work is still pending, although the city consultant, SCS Engineers, released a preliminary report to the city on Monday indicating the spike was due to trash from outside the city— notably, from the west side and from Six Flags Magic Mountain and the Pitchess Detention Center— being incorrectly attributed to Santa Clarita rather than the unincorporated Los Angeles County territory.
Considering all of this, and the obvious level of remaining uncertainty about the trash diversion numbers, it was puzzling, then, to see the city staff asking the City Council to approve a memorandum of understanding Tuesday night that would have put the terms of the new hauler contracts into action— albeit without officially committing the city to the new contracts.
Fortunately, the council recognized that it’s better to sit tight while the waste diversion issue is sorted out: Council members voted unanimously to wait, rather than approve the MOU.
“It is inappropriate to move ahead in any way, shape or form,” Councilman Bob Kellar said. “We should wait until the report.” Kellar is right.
To his credit, Blue Barrel General Manager Karl McCarthy acknowledged that the council had taken the appropriate action. “I understand exactly where they’re coming from,” he said. “I think they did the right thing.”
Absolutely. Until the waste diversion issue is fully understood— and methods of preventing a repeat of the scenario are devised— it would be premature for the council to move forward with a new agreement with the waste haulers.
Prudence was called for on Tuesday night, and the council delivered it.
