The city has the moral high ground on this one— and opponents of Santa Clarita’s proposed sphere of influence have no moral basis to support their position.
None.
For the third time, Santa Clarita is asking the Los Angeles County Local Agency Formation Commission to grant the city a sphere of influence extending beyond the city’s boundaries.
The sphere of influence would give the city no legislative authority over territory outside city limits, but would give the city the formal right to have its input considered on land use decisions within the sphere.
The city has been beating the pavement seeking local support for the proposed sphere, which envisions the possible areas that may someday constitute the city of Santa Clarita—Êin other words, the territory the city may eventually have to serve.
If land is included within the sphere, it doesn’t guarantee that it will someday annex to the city. Decisions on annexations— or even the possible formation of new cities— would be left to future landowners.
Rather, a sphere of influence would simply give the city a more prominent role at the negotiating table when new developments are proposed in unincorporated territory, and help ensure that the concerns of existing residents are addressed when the county approves new residential growth.
So far, the city has rounded up some key allies in its third attempt for a sphere of influence. Having been defeated twice— in 1989 because the city did not yet have a general plan and in 1992 because the city supposedly didn’t have a sufficient financial track record for LAFCO’s taste—Êthe city now seems to have all of its ducks in a row.
Except for one uncooperative duck.
The city has a well-thought-out general plan. It has established itself as a solvent entity, capable of managing itself efficiently. It has local school officials and other key leaders aboard with its sphere proposal.
However, some key opponents remain. Perhaps most notably is The Newhall Land and Farming Co.
Newhall Land is certainly the Santa Clarita Valley’s biggest developer— and arguably its best one. The local company owns some 15,000 acres west of Interstate 5 that would be within the proposed sphere of influence, including the 12, 000-acre Newhall Ranch project.
There’s no moral reason Santa Clarita shouldn’t have a right to influence development just outside its borders. New growth outside the city affects a plethora of issues within the city, including roads and schools.
And remember: Inclusion in the sphere gives the city no new legislative power; development decisions in the sphere would remain in the hands of Los Angeles County. The sphere, in essence, only guarantees Santa Clarita a figurative advisory seat at the bargaining table.
Newhall Land’s opposition could prove to be no small factor: LAFCO historically has listened to land owners when making boundary decisions, as evidenced by the insane way the original 1987 city of Santa Clarita boundaries were carved around the “omit my property please” requests from an assortment of land owners and developers.
If Newhall Land tells LAFCO it doesn’t want its property included in the city’s sphere, it wouldn’t be at all surprising to see the LAFCO grant the developer’s wish.
That would be unfortunate.
The city and Newhall Land have in the years since 1987 developed a mostly cooperative relationship, working together one several notable projects, including the Bridgeport development and the North Valencia II annexation. One would think that relationship would assuage any fears Newhall Land might have about the city gaining influence on county development decisions— and even if that relationship were to somehow sour, the sphere of influence still would not put real decision-making power in the city’s hands.
Bottom line: The sphere of influence is nothing more than a guarantee that the city and its existing residents will have a formal right to comment on new growth outside city limits.
And there’s no moral reason to oppose that.
