It’s alarming how often public officials presume that government records shouldn’t be released to the public. All too often, a request for public records is met with hesitation, foot-dragging , even flat refusal.
‘It’s important to remember that governments— from the city to the state and federal levels— are doing the public’s business, and they must do so publicly.’
But it’s important to remember that governments— from the city to the state and federal levels— are doing the public’s business, and they must do so publicly, even if it’s uncomfortable for the bureaucrats who wish to keep information close to the vest.
That’s why it’s important that the state Legislature approve several public-information bills that are making their way through the legislative process in Sacramento.
The bills, supported by the California First Amendment Coalition, target topics like overriding public interest in disclosure of government records; improper use of closed-session meetings; and secret settlements of private-party lawsuits that have broad consumer-sensitive issues.
Specifically, in the interest of improving public access to government, the Legislature should approve the following:
• Assembly Bill 914: The “Public Interest Override” bill, by Assemblyman Kevin Shelley, D-San Francisco, is set for a hearing Monday before the Assembly Committee on Governmental Organization. The bill would add a new code to the California Public Records Act, reversing an existing “balancing test” in which public officials can attempt to justify non-disclosure of otherwise public records by demonstrating that secrecy is in the public interest. AB 914 essentially reverses the balancing test, instead requiring the public agency to demonstrate that public interest would be seriously harmed by disclosure.
• AB1050: A new set of regulations governing closed sessions regarding “real property,” goes before the Assembly Local Government Committee on Wednesday. Authored by Assemblywoman Christine Kehoe, D-San Diego, would tighten the restrictions on allowable closed sessions for real property negotiations under the Ralph M. Brown Act. Governments often abuse the real property provisions of the Brown Act, engaging in closed sessions that really should be public. The measure is sponsored by the California Newspaper Publishers Association.
• AB 36 and Senate Bill 11: These twin bills, by Assemblyman Darrell Steinberg and Sen. Martha Escutia, D-Montebello , are designed to make it more difficult for parties in some consumer-sensitive lawsuits to keep settlements— as well as information produced in discovery— shielded from the public. Supporters of the bill, including the Consumer Attorneys of California, have cited instances such as 1994 earthquake lawsuits and the Firestone tires lawsuits as examples of why such legislation is in the public’s best interest.
Each of these bills has the goal of ensuring that the public’s business is conducted in the public’s full view. Hopefully, all three will be passed and signed into law— and serve as important reminders to government officials who all too often view the public’s right to know with suspicion and disdain.
