This community and its leaders have been through the ringer in the past week. But through it all, one positive result has occurred:
The city, at long last, will invoke its auditing powers over the three franchised trash haulers.
The audit was announced Friday after a lengthy closed-session meeting in which the City Council considered the possibility of firing City Manager George Caravalho.
The council announced the meeting on the same day as a Signal news story regarding a lawsuit settlement in which a former city employee received a $325,000 settlement before the trial could begin. That employee, former solid waste coordinator Hazel Joanes, alleged that Caravalho and another top city staffer told her to keep quiet when she protested that city trash rates were too high— and that the haulers were making more money than they were supposed to under the terms of the franchise contracts.
Certainly, Caravalho’s handling— and mishandling— of the trash situation is one factor that has led to mounting dissatisfaction among certain council members. However, it was but one of several factors. For months, several council members have privately complained that it doesn’t seem as if the council’s direction always translates into city staff action on a variety of issues.
Clearly, the Caravalho issue has been brewing for some time. And it wasn’t just about the Joanes lawsuit.
But when the council met to discuss Caravalho’s status, one of the outcomes of the hours-long meeting was an order by the council that the books of the three haulers— Blue Barrel, Atlas and Santa Clarita Disposal— shall be audited to determine exactly how much profit the haulers have been making, how much they pay in “tipping fees” at landfills and to address the question of whether Santa Claritans are overpaying.
By all appearances, they are. The $22.13 monthly rate paid by Santa Clarita residents for trash and recycling service is roughly $5 per month more than many nearby, similar cities.
And, according to the Joanes lawsuit, the haulers were making a profit in the mid-1990s when landfill tipping fees were approximately $34 per ton. The haulers won’t say what their tipping fees are now, and city officials don’t know because they haven’t bothered to ask, but sources say Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita disposal— both owned by Waste Management Inc. — were paying as little as $11 per ton in 1999, yet residents’ rates had not dropped.
The city’s landfill dumping and waste diversion numbers are in question for the past several years, but more than 150 million tons of trash were attributed to the city last year. At a savings of $23 per ton during the mid-1990s , tipping fees, multiplied by, for example, the 183,000 tons of trash attributed to the city in 1999, divided by approximately 42,000 households, approximately $100 extra is being paid per year, per household. That would translate to an extra $4 million per year in profit.
Perhaps those numbers aren’t accurate. They are, admittedly, guesswork. But they are only guesswork because your city, since the inception of the franchises in 1991, has never audited the haulers, as the city is empowered to do under the franchise agreements.
It’s entirely possible that there are other factors that result in a reasonable profit for the haulers and justify the high rates Santa Claritans pay. But the city has never bothered to check.
Until now. As part of its discussion on the future of George Caravalho, the City Council decided to order an independent audit of the haulers’ numbers.
Hopefully, that order will translate to a credible audit by a firm that will be beholden to the City Council and taxpayers, not the city staff. And hopefully, it will lay to rest all of the questions surrounding the city trash deals, and help the City Council make an informed decision for a change when it makes the final call on whether to sign new contracts with the existing haulers or go out to bid in search of a better deal for taxpayers.
If that proves to be the case, then indeed something very positive will have come out of all of the political turmoil that the community endured this week.
